Stories of the Supernatural
  • Stories of the Supernatural
    • Stories of the Supernatural Podcast
    • Stories of the Supernatural Video Links
  • Miami Ghost Chronicles
  • M.P. Pellicer | Author
    • Books by M.P. Pellicer
    • Paranormal Chit Chat with Marlene
  • Stranger Than Fiction Stories
  • Eerie News
  • Supernatural Storytime
    • Supernatural StoryTime Podcasts
    • Supernatural StoryTime Videos
  • Paranormal Podcasts
  • Haunted Places
    • Anderson's Corner
    • Animal Hauntings
    • Belleview Biltmore Hotel
    • Bobby Mackey's Honky Tonk
    • Brookdale Lodge
    • Chacachacare Island
    • Coral Castle
    • Drayton Hall Plantation
    • ​Jonathan Dickinson State Park
    • Kreischer Mansion
    • Miami Biltmore Hotel
    • Miami Forgotten Properties
    • Myrtles Plantation
    • Pinewood Cemetery
    • Rolling Hills Asylum
    • St. Ann's Retreat
    • Stranahan Cromartie House
    • The Devil Tree
    • Trans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum
    • West Virginia Penitentiary
  • Videos
  • Astrology Horoscope & Zodiac
    • Astrology Today
    • Horoscope
    • Zodiac
  • Merch
    • FILES

Shadowed Frames: Cursed Canvas, Unsettled Spirits, and the Art of the Haunting

8/9/2024

 
Shadowed Frames: Cursed Canvas, Unsettled Spirits, and the Art of the Haunting
Dimly lit taverns, smoke-hazy lounges, and shadowy basements often hold our fondest memories—or our most blood-chilling horrors. There are spirits poured neatly over ice, and then there are Spirits that linger in the dark, tethered to pigment, wood, and thread. Canvas and ink are meant to capture life, yet sometimes they entrap something far more sinister. The following accounts chronicle the unnerving, unexplained phenomena surrounding haunted portraits and cursed artwork—where the boundary between the medium and the unseen world dangerously dissolves.

PictureMont Robinson a bartender who drowned himself haunted the gravel pit where he died c.1893
Perhaps being a bartender comes with its own special risk, unknown to the casual observer.

In February, 1893, J.M. "Mont" Robinson, a bartender who lived in Summitville, Indiana, drowned himself. He went to a gravel pit filled with water near town, and left his coat and hat on the shore. He was 40 years old, and left behind a wife and four children. He had some financial reverses, and his health was bad.


The pond was deep, and saloon men from where he worked had been cutting ice from it during the cold weather. The next day, his boss passed by and saw the hat and coat on the bank. Right away he realized they belonged to Robinson.

Suspecting what the man had done, he went back to town and brought a party of friends with grab hooks and dragged the bottom thoroughly. Eventually the body was found and taken to his home. It seemed that once Robinson lived in "good circumstances" and owned a farm near Summitville, but he lost it through bad management and sickness.

Less than a month after he died, Mont Robinson was seen near the pool where he drowned. People who passed by the area at night, which was half a mile outside of town, would see him standing on the bank as if in the act of plunging into the pool. It seemed he didn't realize he had been successful in ending his life.

Picture
The writer of the story gave this example as similar to the one that was central to his story.
The Spirit of the Bartender
​

Last year, my junior year of college, me and 4 other friends moved into a house together. We all brought our own things to decorate the house with (posters, paintings, etc.). One of the paintings was of a bartender pouring a martini. We would end up calling this painting the Martini Man. I had a weird feeling about it right off the bat. His wide eyes would follow you around the room, and there was just something creepy about it. When you were alone with it, it still felt like there was a real presence with you. About a month or two after the move in, activity started happening.

One day, I was sitting on the couch in the living room playing some video games, I started hearing slamming at the front door, and it was LOUD. It sounded like somebody sprinting and body-slamming the door (BTW we have a foyer so I can't see the door from the living room). Thinking it may have been a loud knock, I go to see if there's anyone there. Nothing. This persists throughout the day, and I get up several more times to see if anyone is there. Nothing each time. It's the middle of the day so I'm more confused than creeped out. I decide to test the door, shaking it, slamming it, knocking on it, even jumping into it. Nothing I did was close to as loud as the noises I was hearing. To top it off, this happened one day and one day only. I never heard this happen again. Not necessarily attributed to the painting, but I’ll explain how it connects later.

The last personal story is about the footsteps. This happened in the summer, when it was just me and one other guy living in the house. It was about 2 am, and I was lying in bed playing on my laptop. I start hearing really loud footsteps coming from downstairs. They were like fast stomps. It sounded like someone sprinting while completely drunk. At first I just though it was a drunken roommate, but there was something strange in the pattern to them. I would hear them start in one part of the house, stomp to another, stop for a while, then pick back up in a completely different part of the house.

Eventually, they came running up the stairs, directly to my door, and stopped. I was frozen with fear during the silence. They then started up again, downstairs this time. It kept going for at least 10 more minutes.

I should probably explain why I pin all this on the painting and not the house itself. As I already said, its eyes would follow you around the room, and had an overall creepy vibe to it. People would come over and say that the painting scared them without hearing any of these stories. We had some girls over for a party and they insisted that we take the painting down. I hastily agreed and took it off the wall. That's when I saw, written on the back of the canvas, the name of the painting: "The Spirit of the Bartender". Quite frankly I thought this was hilarious, as I had been expressing my distaste for this painting to my roommate for some time, and this corroborated my claims nicely.

After that year, the roommate to whom it belonged moved out, and he took the painting with him. The activity died down after that. He ended up giving it to the bar he worked at, and they threw it out after only 2 weeks. I can imagine why. We actually managed to find the artist on the internet, and it seems he just paints the same thing over and over again. I'll attach an image of one of his works that's closest to what we had in our home.
Lost at Sea, Bound to Frame

My sister was a maritime artist. She committed suicide last July in West Palm Beach. My wife and I brought a lot of her unsold pieces back, some are really well done. So we hung several of the larger ones

Mean while my sister's ashes got lost in the mail when the mortuary sent them back to me in Houston, Texas. It took two months and her remains made several round trips from Florida and back. However my sister did love to travel. Once the ashes finally arrived is when the trouble started.

When we get in a argument about her, one of the paintings always falls off the wall. Her ashes are in the guest bedroom closet. The guest bedroom was our three house cats' favorite afternoon hang out, now they refuse to go in there.
My father-in-law has a Hatteras with a large enclosed cabin that can accommodate several people. We are going to invite some of my sister's closest friends and go out a bit in deeper water. There is a large back deck and a door in the transom so you can step down near the water. We will go when the weather is calm this summer, spread her ashes, and give our cats their hang-out pad back
Picture
Picture mentioned by commentator that is found at the John Ringling Museum
The Demon in the Emerald Abyss

"I visited the John Ringling Museum of Art and Estate in Sarasota, FL a few years back. There was a haunted painting there. It was a portrait of a young woman, wearing a deep emerald bodice and a blue scarf on her head as she looked down with her body turned down a bit, and it cast a shadow on her breast. I took a photo because the depth of the emerald velvet bodice seemed to be an abyss, it was so dark and the painting had a licked surface, which Dutch painters from the Renaissance era would use as a technique to diminish brush stroke textures so that colors and implied textures were more intense. I remember getting stuck on this piece. Her eyes were so sad, the textures we're so rich! Too rich. Too perfect. I decided I didn't like this work after all.

When I was later looking through my pictures, I noticed a red devil or demon looking thing where that deep abyss of dark green emerald was when I saw it in person, on the wall. I showed so many people this picture and asked them if they saw anything unusual and every single person saw that red demon right away. It was NOT on the painting at the museum, but it showed up on my picture.
No other photos had these red obstructions, or whatever, in them, but I took multiple pictures of this paintings from different angles and every picture has the red demon."
The Blue-Grey Gown
What transpires when parents unknowingly introduce a conduit of malevolence into the family home?
​

"This story entails a painting that my mother brought home from an auction when I was about 8. My parents imported and exported antiques and fine wines for many years.

My mother Natasha is Russian born but grew up in the USA from the age of 3, and always had the love of anything old and unusual when it came to furniture and artworks. Something that seems to have rubbed off on me a little.

My parents would regularly go to auctions and estate sales and liked to purchase interesting pieces for their business. It was rare that anything purchased at these sales ever made it home to become part of our house, unless it was out of the ordinary or my parents liked it too much to part with it.

My childhood home looked like a cross between a madman's idea of a yard sale and an antiques market belonging to an insane hoarder. But it made for good fun and interesting conversation. And many a good fort.

None of the furniture or artworks had previously bothered me as far as I can remember, until my mother purchased a painting by an unknown artist (it's never been signed and research has never uncovered who painted it or who the subject actually is). All we knew is that the family who put it in the auction bought the home they had found it in, and didn't like the painting or several pieces of furniture that the last owners had left behind. So off to the sales they went. It was a rather large lot of over 50 items. My mother purchased the painting and a sideboard full of silverware and plates of varying ages locked inside (we got them open after we got it home. It was strange as my mother had been told it was empty. Not so much as it turned out.).

The painting is of a women of about 30 years old (maybe older but it's hard to tell) wearing a long blue-grey gown standing in a veranda of an old house. Next to her is a table with a tea set and kettle and what looks like some cake or sandwiches on a plate. There are some flowers and a chair and part of a window. Whoever did the painting had a lot of talent as the detail is incredible. It was probably painted around 1900-1910, judging by the fashion she's wearing.

My mother brought it home and we hung it in the hallway next to my parent's bedroom between the main bathroom and a little room my dad used to do his paperwork in.
I felt very strange around the painting from the first day it was hanging up. The hallway in summer was comfortable and not too warm but after the painting was hung up the area around the painting turned almost ice cold. Passing the painting I'd get goose bumps on whatever exposed skin I had.

I also started feeling like the lady in the painting was watching me. My twin sisters started saying that they didn't like looking at the painting as it made them feel uncomfortable, and like they weren't meant to be around it. My baby brother would walk on the other side of the hallway to it. And when asked why, he said he didn't like the lady and that he was cold when he looked at her (he was 5 at the time nearly 6).

Soon it went past just feelings in the hallway. At night we'd start hearing whispers that hadn't been there previously. Our house already had its share of spooky behavior we had gotten used to, but this was new.

Movement of a flash of blue-grey like the dress out of the corner of your eye. A strange touch occasionally in the hallway when no one else was around. This may sound like something from Tales From the Crypt but I assure you this isn't something I saw on TV. I only wished sometimes it was.

After my father (6'5", 350 pounds of him) got a cold hand run up his back when he was in the shower, was when any real notice of what we all had said to our parents got attention. Since we were use to other ghosts in the house, we at first thought oh it's just another spirit making itself known to us as its new here.

But then things got bad. Fast!

  • My baby brother (let's call him Adam) was tripped on the stairs and pushed by a cold hand when he tried to get up again.

  • The big fern we had in the hall next to the painting suddenly started dying. It was over 20 years old and had no previous problems. When we moved it away from the painting it went back to being fine. It's still alive today, but one side of it looks a little mangled (the side facing the painting never was the same. The branches grew back weird like something had infected them. It was checked out and tested by plant specialist and they couldn't find anything wrong with the old plant).

  • Our dogs Frankie and Dex (both terrier mixes) wouldn't go past the painting without whining or growling at it. They were normally very placid and gentle dogs. Our aunt's dog Lula (a poodle) had to be carried past it when we used to babysit her; she wouldn't walk past it or even look at it.

  • Our cats tried to claw at it one time when it fell off its hook onto the ground. Our normally placid Maine coon cats Sally and Meg both went nuts trying to scratch it until we took it away.

  • It started coming off the hook every night and sat against the wall upright every morning when no one touched it.

My mother a very spiritual person who put up with our friendly spirits in the house with a grain of salt as they didn't bother her, decided that this painting had to go and something was wrong with it. To which we all agreed.

So off to the auctions it went. Several times. My mother who knew the buyers found out they only kept it a month (they too heard whispers and their cat also attacked the painting) and gave it to a neighbor who liked it. The neighbor sold it, after her dog freaked out around it.

It kept getting sold on or auctioned or given away until 2014, when a man who collected art in Florida bought the painting and did not know of its history. Having again tried to research it's past. He only found out it was possibly a painting of an artist's wife who died young. I don't know if it's true of not. There is no real record of the artwork anywhere and it's not signed. The man who owned it last I heard keeps it in his basement, as it frightened his grandchildren. He says he won't sell it on, and keeps it locked up. I think too he knows something isn't right with it. I'm worried as he's old; what's going to happen when he dies?

This painting I think isn't safe. Either a ghost is in it or attached to it, and it's not friendly. It really should be destroyed.

I know it probably sounds like a made up story for kids. And a adult man like myself shouldn't be weary of an old oil painting of someone unknown. This painting is dangerous.
PicturePeople see different and sometimes terrifying images in this painting
The Unnamed Malevolence of Horseley Fields

The most disturbing artwork often hides behind deceptive normalcy. A simple portrait can appear harmless until the eye lingers, revealing a creeping dread that leaves observers desperate to escape.
​
Psychic Philip Solomon acquired a notorious portrait with a long history of terrorizing its owners. Its dark legacy began three decades earlier when a friend purchased it from a shop in Horseley Fields, Wolverhampton. The canvas bounced from buyer to buyer, even traveling across the Atlantic to America, yet it inevitably returned to Willenhall. The identity of the original painter remains unknown, along with the source of the malicious energy trapped within its fibers. Are these accounts true, or are they mere urban myths echoing through time

​Solomon noted how the object maintained its grip, and he recounted the following:

From the moment she got it home, my friend had problems with the painting. It kept falling off the wall of its own accord and terrifying her children who said people came out of the painting. She asked me if I would take it off her hands which I did. But, I have to be honest, it even unnerved me. I quickly sold it on to a lady who had a bric-a-brac shop on Walsall Road, WIllenhall. But she had big problems with it, too. It scared people and some even fainted after looking at it. Dogs also hate it. Once more, it came back to me free of charge.

I let a family member have it who actually liked it. A month later it was returned to me with the comment 'strange things are happening'. I thought the best thing to do was just keep it in my garden shed, wrapped and covered. My dog hated it, immediately growling and barking at it. Staff at the Robin said they were really scared by it. I put it on my Facebook page and from all quarters we had reports of the same visions that were seen in the past.
PictureThe Anguished Man comes from an unknown artist and is undated
The Anguished Man

This horrific legend began as online lore before manifesting as a physical nightmare. The tortured portrait was allegedly created by an artist who mixed his own blood into the pigments before ending his life.

Sean Robinson inherited the painting from his grandmother, who harbored a deep terror of the piece and swore it was cursed. Once hung on a wall, the standard paranormal cadence began: dark silhouettes drifting through hallways, disembodied crying, and raspy whispers cutting through the silence of the night.

Robinson, residing in Cumbria, U.K., documented the surreal phenomena in a series of videos released in 2010. He captured metallic scraping sounds emanating from the basement where the painting was quarantined, strange mists coalescing near the stairs, and the visual shadow of a spectral man. Viewers who stared into the painting's agonized face online reported sudden bouts of severe nausea and unexplained nosebleeds. By 2016, the grim tale had attracted filmmakers who acquired the rights to adapt the story into a film.

PictureBekinski's work, all untitled, are dark and apocalyptical
The Nightmare Canvases of Zdzisław Beksiński
​

Zdzisław Beksiński (1929–2005) was a Polish painter whose haunting, untitled works evoke visceral dread. Plagued by severe OCD and agoraphobia—which he morbidly dubbed "neurotic diarrhea"—Beksiński was a self-taught artist whose work spanned from the 1960s into the 1980s. He depicted desolate, apocalyptic worlds overflowing with decaying landscapes, skeletal monoliths, and weeping, mutated figures. Beksiński consistently refused to assign titles or offer interpretations for his work, leaving the dark imagery open to the observer's worst fears.

Tragedy shadowed the artist's personal life. His wife, Zofia, died in 1998; just one year later, on Christmas Eve, Beksiński discovered the body of his son, Tomasz, who had died by a deliberate drug overdose. The final blow came in 2005, when Beksiński was brutally stabbed 17 times in his apartment by the teenage son of his caretaker over a refused $100 loan. An eerie belief persists among collectors: those who gaze into Beksiński's hellish vistas for too long invite an untimely death.

Picture
Untitled c.1978
Picture
Zszislaw Beksinski c.1978
Picture
One of several untitled works by Zszislaw Beksinski
PictureMan Proposes, God Disposes by Edwin Landseer c.1864
Man Proposes, God Disposes
Painted in 1864 by Sir Edwin Landseer, this macabre masterpiece imagines the gruesome fate of Sir John Franklin’s doomed 1845 Arctic expedition. Housed at Royal Holloway, University of London, the painting depicts two polar bears savagely tearing apart the remains of the crew amidst jagged ice and broken wood. The grim imagery was a comment on the tragic fate of the 129 men who disappeared in the Arctic. The painting was so disturbing that Lady Franklin reportedly could not bear to look at it.

Landseer was an artistic child prodigy who, during his lifetime, painted and produced sculptures. He was encouraged by one of his teachers to perform dissections of animals in order to fully understand musculature and skeletal structure. He formally exhibited his work at the age of 13. He was commissioned to create the lion sculptures in Trafalgar Square in London.  The sculptures were installed in 1867, showing gigantic sphinx-like cats measuring 20 feet long, 11 feet high, and weighing seven tons.

He became a wealthy bachelor. In the late 1830s, he suffered a mental breakdown and, for the rest of his life, was troubled by recurring bouts of melancholy, hypochondria, and depression, often aggravated by alcohol and drug use. In the last three and a half years of his life, his mental instability was problematic, with his talented hand and brain becoming increasingly feeble, and at the request of his family, he was declared insane in July of 1872. 

During exam season, the staff routinely cover the canvas of Landseer's work with a Union Flag. Rumor holds that in the 1970s, a student was driven to madness while staring at the painting during an examination, taking his own life and leaving behind a final note: "The polar bears made me do it." While the suicide remains unverified, generations of students swear that sitting near the piece induces an overwhelming feeling of despair and cognitive failure.

Landseer’s grim visual was inspired by real-world horror. The HMS Erebus and HMS Terror vanished without a trace despite carrying years of provisions. Later search expeditions, aided by Inuit accounts, uncovered skeletal remains on King William Island that bore unmistakable evidence of desperate cannibalism.

PictureThe Hands Resist Him by Bill Stoneham c.1974
The Hands Resist Him

Created in 1974 by artist Bill Stoneham, The Hands Resist Him is widely considered one of the most notoriously cursed pieces of modern art. The painting depicts a young boy standing beside a hollow-eyed, life-sized glass doll in front of a glass door, against which dozens of pale, disembodied hands press from the darkness.

The piece drew global attention in 2000 when a seller listed it on eBay with an explicit paranormal warning. The listing stated that the characters in the painting would fight or step out of the frame at night:

At the time we wondered a little why a seemingly perfectly fine painting would be discarded like that (today we don't!!!). One morning our 4 and 1/2 year old daughters claimed that the children in the picture were fighting, and coming into the room during the night.​
PictureBill Stoneham, self portrait (Source - Stoneham Studios)
​The eBay listing logged over 30,000 views, with users reporting strange physical reactions simply from viewing the digital thumbnail—including sudden illness, psychological blackouts, and the urge to burn white sage to cleanse their homes.

Though the seller eventually attempted to tone down the claims, a trail of real-world tragedy surrounds the piece. Between 1978 and 1984, three key men connected to the painting died: LA Times art critic Henry Seldis (suicide, 1978), gallery owner Charles Feingarten (cancer, 1981), and actor John Marley, who originally purchased the painting (died during heart surgery, 1984). The painting was ultimately acquired by a private collector, while its sequels and prequels continue to provoke unease among paranormal historians.

PictureReplica of the Love Letters
Replica of Love Letters
​

Hanging on the fifth floor of the historic Driskill Hotel in Austin, Texas, this harmless-looking portrait conceals a tragedy. The painting depicts a young girl holding flowers, closely resembling four-year-old Samantha Houston—the daughter of Texas Senator Temple Houston—who tragically fell to her death down the hotel’s grand staircase in 1887 while chasing a leather ball.

Her father was Senator Temple Houston, and her grandfather was General Sam Houston.

Her sister Louise, age 2, died the same year from cholera infantum and was buried in the same Mobeetie Cemetery as Samantha. In 1897, the couple lost another baby that was one month old.

The painting titled Replica of Love Letters was produced by Richard King from an original painted by Charles Trevor Garland (1866-1906), a British artist.

People who have viewed it, not only the one in the hotel but replicas, report nausea and uneasy feelings around it that they cannot account for, since the subject is so innocuous.

Guests and staff report that the little girl's facial expression visibly shifts when no one is looking directly at her. Others report the sound of giggling and the phantom bouncing of a ball echoing down empty hallways near the frame. Visitors viewing simple photographic replicas of the painting often experience unexplained motion sickness, dizziness, and a sudden, oppressive sense of grief.

PictureBernardo Vicente de Gálvez y Madrid, 1st Count of Gálvez (1746 – 1786)
The Ghost of Gálvez

The Grand Galvez Resort in Galveston, Texas, houses a striking, full-length portrait of Bernardo de Gálvez, the 18th-century Spanish military leader and Governor of Louisiana. While many historic portraits feature eyes that seem to track the viewer, the Gálvez painting possesses a far more peculiar reputation: travelers attempting to photograph the artwork often find their images ruined by unnatural blurriness, cold spots, or dark light artifacts—unless they explicitly ask the Count's permission before snapping the photo.

The hotel itself sits upon grounds steeped in sorrow. Built in 1911 over the site of the former St. Mary's Orphan Asylum—which was completely swept away in the horrific Galveston Hurricane of 1900, taking 93 children and 10 nuns—the resort is home to scores of restless spirits.

​Another hurricane roared into Galveston in 1915, claiming 275 lives — yet the hotel, unlike the orphanage nearby, survived.

During Prohibition, a speakeasy operated within its walls. By the years of World War II, it had become a U.S. Coast Guard station, its halls empty of the tourists who once filled them.

Reports of the unexplained still drift through the 226-room structure. Room 501 is tied to the legend of the Ghost Bride. As the story goes, a young woman used to climb to a hatch on the roof and gaze out to sea, waiting for her sailor to come home. Word reached her that he'd been lost with his ship. Grief-stricken, she hanged herself in the hotel's west turret. It's little wonder, then, that her spirit is said to linger still.

Other apparitions haunt the lower floors — a little girl bouncing a ball, a man glimpsed in the hotel laundry. Children's laughter drifts near one of the bathrooms and the Music Hall. A ghostly maid makes her rounds, and a man has been seen walking straight through a closed door.

Given how long the Galvez has stood, it's no surprise so many spirits might call it home. But one incident, occurring just three years after the hotel first opened its doors, stands apart — a case unsettling enough that it alone could explain a restless ghost.

PictureHotel Galvez, postcard
The Girl on the Beach

In 1914, the body of a beautiful young woman was found shot to death on Galveston Beach, within sight of the hotel. Suicide seemed the obvious explanation — until the details refused to add up. There were no powder burns at the wound. No weapon was ever recovered. No signs of struggle marred the sand. No one on the boulevard reported hearing a gunshot, or a cry for help. Her clothing — fine, expensive — bore no identifying marks, and she wore no jewelry at all.

A Galvez Hotel employee discovered her body half-buried by the high tide. The physicians who examined her found that the bullet had passed clean through — a wound that would have killed her instantly. Whatever blood had spilled at the scene, the waves had long since carried away.

Police theorized she might be the daughter of a wealthy family — lured to the beach, then robbed and murdered. She wore an expensive white dress of sheer fabric, new tan shoes, and matching silk stockings. Beside her lay a Panama hat and a single glove. She was strikingly beautiful: long, dark hair, gray eyes, no trace of makeup, and about 5'5" tall.

Later that afternoon, investigators found something curious near the body — a small figurine of the Virgin Mary. Police began checking whether she'd attended services at St. Mary's Cathedral, searching for any thread that might lead to her name.

On July 22, 1914, newspapers reported she might be Mrs. George Hopper of Cleburne, Texas. The lead went nowhere.

Investigators also learned that on the night of the murder, several quarrels had broken out along the beach. One in particular stood out: a man and woman had driven up to the resort. He went in to arrange accommodations; she refused to leave the car. A violent argument erupted before the couple sped off into the dark.

PictureWas Elvira Davis murdered? c.1914 (Source - The Austin American)
A Name, At Last

Finally, on July 24, cousins came forward and identified the woman: Elvira Davis of San Antonio, private secretary and librarian to the wealthy capitalist George W. Brackenridge. One theory took hold — that given her state of undress, lacking underskirts or petticoats, she'd been murdered inside the hotel, then dressed and carried down to the beach afterward.

Brackenridge admitted he'd received a business letter from her the week before, though he insisted it gave no hint of any intent to end her life — a claim he would later recant. Rumor also spread that she feared cancer, the disease that had killed her sister, and that she suffered from chronic rheumatism of her own.

Police floated yet another theory: that she'd been part of an automobile party that drove out to the beach, where she met her death for reasons unknown. The coroner's official ruling was maddeningly vague — death by "a bullet fired by some person or persons unknown."

Two weeks later, Governor Colquitt offered a $200 reward for the arrest and conviction of her killer.
​
The Verdict That Wouldn't Hold

Despite the coroner's findings, the grand jury reversed course by the first week of August, ruling her death a suicide. The police disagreed — insisting she'd been murdered — and no one ever explained why the official story had changed.

The police chief went further still, casting doubt on her very identity. Chief Perrett claimed he could produce affidavits showing the dead woman was no older than 24 — while Elvira Davis had been 44. That discrepancy, paired with the absence of powder burns and the absence of water in her lungs, cast serious doubt on the suicide ruling. Bruises marked her face, evidence of a beating before death. Fingerprints were found on her throat.

And yet — complicating the murder theory just as thoroughly — was a farewell letter sent to her employer, and a telegram to a friend, Dr. Schaefer. In them, she wrote that hereditary rheumatism was overtaking her, that she had no one left depending on her, and that she couldn't bear becoming helpless in the care of others. Her parents and four of her siblings had already passed.

A Mystery That Never Closed

So which was it — murder, or suicide? And was the body even Elvira's at all? Four years before her death, she'd been living quietly in Benicia, California. After the inquest, the search for a killer simply faded away, even as police continued to insist she'd met with foul play.

Perhaps she is one of the restless ones — the kind who cannot lie quiet in the grave. Perhaps she still walks the halls of the Galvez Hotel, waiting, like the bride of Room 501, for an ending that never comes.
​


Comments are closed.

    Stories of the Supernatural Podcast

    Picture
    Stories of the Supernatural listen to episodes without commercial interruption on your browser or download the mp3 file

    RSS Feed

    Noir Notebook Dead men tell no tales. I write them anyway.
    Noir Notebook Dead men tell no tales. I write them anyway.
    Supernatural Storytime 150,000 download award

    Marlene
    ​Narrator, Host & Producer

    Of the video / podcast series: Stories of the Supernatural, which presents episodes about all the mysteries of the paranormal world,
    as well as Nightshade Diary, Supernatural Storytime and Eerie.News

    Picture
    Dead men tell no tales. I write them anyway.

    Archives

    October 2026
    September 2026
    August 2026
    July 2026
    June 2026
    May 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    January 2026
    December 2025
    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    August 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017

    Categories

    All
    Afterlife And Near Death Experience
    Alien Abduction
    Alternate Realities
    Ancestor Spirits & Totems
    Ancient Aliens
    Ancient America
    Angelic And Marian Messages
    Animal Spirits And Totems
    Apocalypse And End Times
    Archaeology Mysteries
    Astrology And Metaphysics
    Asylums & Prisons
    Atlantis & Other Lost Civilizations
    Bermuda Triangle & Other Earth Mysteries
    Bigfoot Stories
    Black Magic Ritual
    Cattle Mutilations
    Cemetery Story
    Cemetery Urbex
    Christmas Ghost Stories
    Coincidence And Synchronicity
    Cold Case
    Conspiracy Theories
    Crime Stories
    Cryptid Encounters
    Cults And Covens
    Cursed Object
    Cursed Places
    Dark Folklore
    Demonic Possession
    Dogman & Other Cryptids
    Everglades Curse
    Exorcism And Demonic Cases
    Extraterrestrials
    Feng Shui & Earth Energies
    Fortune Telling And Divination
    Freemasons And Other Secret Societies
    Fringe Science
    Ghost Hunter Stories
    Ghost Stories
    Ghost Towns & Haunted Mines
    Halloween
    Hat Man & Shadow People
    Haunted Antiques & Needful Things
    Haunted Asylums And Hospitals
    Haunted California
    Haunted Castles And Mansions
    Haunted Convents & Holy Places
    Haunted England
    Haunted Florida
    Haunted Highway
    Haunted Hollywood
    Haunted Hotels & Inns
    Haunted Houses & Disturbed Land
    Haunted New Mexico
    Haunted Railroads And Airports
    Haunted Roads & Byways
    Haunted Rock & Roll
    Haunted Ships & Nautical Mysteries
    Haunted Trading Post
    Hexes And Curses
    Hidden Treasure
    Historical Mystery
    Hitchhiker Ghost
    Hoodoo & Conjure
    Horror Stories
    Hypnosis
    Jack The Ripper
    Lighthouses And Other Lonely Places
    Magic Practices
    Manifestation And The Law Of Attraction
    Manson Family
    Mardi Gras Stories
    Miami Murder Mystery
    Missing Persons
    Monsters And Dark Legends
    Murder Mystery
    Mysteries Of The Pyramid
    Mystery Of The National Parks
    Mythical Creatures
    Natural Disasters
    Necromancy & Dark Magic
    Occult Hollywood
    Occult Literature
    Old Florida Mystery
    Old West & Frontier Stories
    Ouija-spirit-boards
    Paranormal Chit Chat
    Paranormal Investigation
    Paranormal Investigator
    Paranormal Research
    Paranormal Urbex
    Police & First Responders' Ghost Stories
    Power Of Manifestation
    Psychic And Spiritual Medium
    Psychic Intervention
    Psychic Profiler
    Psychics & Empaths
    Reincarnation & Past Life Regression
    Remote Viewer
    Sacred Space
    Satan & Lucifer
    Scandal & Murder
    Science Fiction
    Secret Burials And Boneyards
    Secret-forgotten-cemeteries
    Secret Teachings
    Self Defense & Survival
    Self Help & Life Coaching
    Serial Killer Story
    Shapeshifters And Skinwalkers
    Southern Gothic
    Spirit Attachment & Influence
    Spiritual Healing
    Spiritualism
    Spiritual Medium
    Spiritual Warfare
    Strange Collection
    Strange Disappearances
    Strange Phenomena
    Super Soldiers
    Superstition & Folklore
    Suppressed History
    Symbolism And Mystery Schools
    Templar Mystery
    Theaters & Actors
    True Crime
    True Ghost Story
    UFO Disclosure
    UFO In The Bible
    UFO Stories
    Urban Myths
    Vampires And Monsters
    Voodoo & Root Work
    War Time Ghosts And Mysteries
    Witchcraft & Occultism

    Image and Graphic Sources

Picture
Picture
CENTRAL FLORIDA MOBILE NOTARY SERVICES
Cash Every Day
Cash Every Day #casheveryday
Picture
Find Where Traditional Latin Masses are Held in the United States
Picture
VISION FOR THE FUTURE: The World Should Be Safe For Children
Picture
Buy me a Cup of Joe!
"When misguided public opinion honors what is despicable and despises what is honorable, punishes virtue and rewards vice, encourages what is harmful and discourages what is useful, applauds falsehood and smothers truth under indifference or insult, a nation turns its back on progress and can be restored only by the terrible lessons of catastrophe."
- Frederic Bastiat
Marlene Pardo Pellicer, author, producer and narrator
M.P. Pellicer
Picture
Send an email
Picture
Copyright © 2009-2026 Free Thinker Projects LLC. 
​ All Rights Reserved ®
​DISCLAIMER

  • Stories of the Supernatural
    • Stories of the Supernatural Podcast
    • Stories of the Supernatural Video Links
  • Miami Ghost Chronicles
  • M.P. Pellicer | Author
    • Books by M.P. Pellicer
    • Paranormal Chit Chat with Marlene
  • Stranger Than Fiction Stories
  • Eerie News
  • Supernatural Storytime
    • Supernatural StoryTime Podcasts
    • Supernatural StoryTime Videos
  • Paranormal Podcasts
  • Haunted Places
    • Anderson's Corner
    • Animal Hauntings
    • Belleview Biltmore Hotel
    • Bobby Mackey's Honky Tonk
    • Brookdale Lodge
    • Chacachacare Island
    • Coral Castle
    • Drayton Hall Plantation
    • ​Jonathan Dickinson State Park
    • Kreischer Mansion
    • Miami Biltmore Hotel
    • Miami Forgotten Properties
    • Myrtles Plantation
    • Pinewood Cemetery
    • Rolling Hills Asylum
    • St. Ann's Retreat
    • Stranahan Cromartie House
    • The Devil Tree
    • Trans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum
    • West Virginia Penitentiary
  • Videos
  • Astrology Horoscope & Zodiac
    • Astrology Today
    • Horoscope
    • Zodiac
  • Merch
    • FILES