Is satanic ritualism on Halloween a myth, or a disturbing reality? Uncover ancient Druid traditions, pet abduction warnings, and real-life murders where malevolent forces and psychological dark turns collide.
Druids practicing human sacrifice
Halloween is often traced to ancient traditions shrouded in darkness.
Long before Rome’s rise, a mysterious priesthood known as the Druids held power across Gaul and Britain. According to later Roman accounts, they ruled through fear, convincing people that the spirits of the dead could cross into the world of the living during a three-day period between the autumnal equinox and the winter solstice. The season was called Samhain—pronounced, some say, “Sow-een.” Roman writers, including Julius Caesar in The Gallic War, claimed that Druid priests demanded each household surrender a family member for sacrifice—or face a curse. Families living under Druid rule were allegedly forced to betray one of their own year after year. It was governance by terror, an extreme form of psychological warfare. The Romans considered these practices so abhorrent that they eventually moved to eradicate the Druid priesthood, reportedly burning its members in the same kind of mass sacrificial fires once used for their victims.
Shadows of Halloween
Today, anyone who warns of Satanic activity during Halloween is often dismissed or ridiculed. But the stories persist. More cats reportedly disappear between August and Halloween than during the rest of the year. Many animal shelters suspend the adoption of black cats in the weeks leading up to Halloween, fearing they could become targets for pranksters or worse. In the 1990s, newspapers even published photographs of cats found mutilated on makeshift altars in parks and abandoned buildings. Since the mid-1990s, critics claim that the media and law enforcement have avoided describing pet abductions or mutilations as “ritualistic,” and have been reluctant to use words such as “cult” or “satanic.” I once spoke informally with a police detective who told me that officers still “see it all the time.” Don't believe media stories that say satanic sacrifice is a "myth" or "urban legend." Pagans believed the midpoint between vernal equinox and winter solstice, after the harvest is in, the spirits of the dead and deities of the netherworld are most accessible, and have the greatest influence. The Humane Society has offered a more cautious warning: “Cats, especially black ones, may be the target of pranksters. Black cat owners are advised to keep their cats safely indoors during the Halloween season.” Right after Halloween 2025, several animals were found mutilated and decapitated in Hudson Valley, New York. They were also drained of blood. The act was described as ritualistic killings. A reward of $2,000 was offered for information leading to information for those responsible. Whether these incidents are acts of organized satanism, cruel pranks, or something more difficult to explain, the fear surrounding them has become part of Halloween’s mythology. When the Veil Thins This year, rather than focus only on organized Satanists, we turn our attention to people who committed terrible acts on Halloween—people who may not have understood what came over them. Some believe that those who surrender themselves to violence, lust, or obsession can open the door to malevolent forces. Others see only psychology: paranoid delusions, dissociation, jealousy, and amnesia. Whatever the explanation, the stories share an unsettling pattern. Search for Halloween alongside words such as “rape,” “murder,” or “bizarre crime,” and a disturbing collection of real-life cases emerges. These two murder cases are examples of heinous crimes perpetrated when the killers were most likely to be influenced by the moment when the veil is thinnest. Patricia and Derek Ward
The Night on Long Island
On the evening of October 28, 2014, the quiet village of Farmingdale, New York, was preparing for Halloween. Porches glowed with decorations, and neighbors were used to seeing eerie displays in the days leading up to the holiday. But what appeared on a street near the Long Island Rail Road station that night was not a decoration. It was the body of 66-year-old Patricia Ward. Patricia was a longtime assistant professor of language arts at Farmingdale State College. Colleagues remembered her as respected, dedicated, and well-liked. Just three months earlier, she had moved into an apartment near the Farmingdale station with her 35-year-old son, Derek Ward. Inside the Apartment According to Nassau County police, Derek attacked his mother inside their second-floor apartment. Investigators later said Patricia suffered multiple stab wounds and broken ribs before being decapitated with a knife. The weapon was recovered from the apartment. Derek then dragged his mother’s body down the stairs, through the building lobby, and into the street. Witnesses described seeing him leave her body outside the apartment building shortly before 8 p.m. A Scene Mistaken for Halloween To those who saw the aftermath, the horror was almost impossible to process. Patricia’s severed head had been kicked roughly 20 feet down the street, and some neighbors initially assumed they were looking at an elaborate Halloween prank. Police were called just before 8 p.m. after a woman’s body was discovered on the pavement outside the building. Only when officers arrived did the neighborhood realize the grim scene was real. The Train Derek Ward left the area on foot. About 25 minutes after his mother’s body was discovered, police received a report that a man had been struck by an eastbound Long Island Rail Road train near the Farmingdale station. The man was Derek. His body was found about a mile from the apartment, less than a quarter mile from where Patricia had been found. Police concluded that he had deliberately stepped in front of the train, dying by suicide. Afterward Investigators classified the case as a murder-suicide. Derek had a reported history of psychiatric problems and prior arrests, but police said there was no documented history of domestic incidents between mother and son, and no clear public motive was ever established. Relatives described Derek as having struggled with mental illness for roughly a decade. His uncle, Father Robert Lubrano, said Derek had shown no prior signs of violence or aggression toward his family. Family members suspected depression and schizophrenia, particularly after Derek reported hearing voices during a psychiatric-hospital stay. In 2013, following the death of his paternal grandfather, Derek reportedly spent six weeks in a Long Island psychiatric hospital. Relatives said he was discharged from psychiatric care about two months before the 2014 killing. He had also stopped taking his medication. Derek’s known criminal history stretched back to 2003, when he received probation for criminal mischief. In 2006, he was arrested and received a short jail term plus probation in a case involving weapons and drug possession, including 100 Valium pills. Police said he also had prior arrests for gun possession and criminal mischief. The Woman Behind the Case Patricia Ward was the mother of Derek Ward and the wife—or former wife—of John Ward, Derek’s father. Her brother was Rev. Robert Lubrano, a Catholic priest. Relatives said Patricia had been trying to support and care for her son, despite the emotional strain it placed on her. In the end, she was remembered not for the violence of her death, but for her decades of teaching and the lasting respect she earned at Farmingdale State College. The murder of Lisa French affected the town and the laws about crimes against children.
The Halloween Night That Changed Fond du Lac
On the evening of October 31, 1973, nine-year-old Lisa Ann French left her home in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin, to go trick-or-treating. She wore a hobo costume—jeans covered with masking tape, a floppy felt hat, and a green parka—and set out shortly before 6 p.m., planning to meet a friend and later attend a neighborhood Halloween party. Lisa lived with her family at 192 Amory Street. She kissed her parents goodbye and walked into the darkening neighborhood, a routine that was common for children in Fond du Lac at the time. The Doorbell Among the houses Lisa visited was the home of Gerald M. Turner Jr., a 25-year-old neighbor and family acquaintance. According to Turner’s later confession, Lisa rang his doorbell with her candy bag open; he invited her inside and lured her to a bedroom. There, Turner sexually assaulted and killed her. An autopsy later found that Lisa died from asphyxiation, with the pathologist also citing circulatory shock caused by sexual trauma. Turner had sodomized her. A Frantic Search When Lisa failed to return home, her family and neighbors began searching. For more than two days, Fond du Lac waited and hoped as police looked for the missing fourth-grader. On November 3, 1973, a farmer driving a tractor spotted two plastic trash bags in brush beside a rural road in the Town of Taycheedah. Inside were Lisa’s body and her Halloween costume. The Investigation Turner became a suspect early in the investigation. Police questioned him repeatedly and examined physical evidence, including hair and fiber comparisons; a polygraph examination was inconclusive. After roughly nine months, Turner confessed on August 8, 1974, to raping and murdering Lisa. He was arrested the following day. Trial and Sentence Turner was the son of Gerald Miles Turner Sr. (1923–1976). Little is known about his mother, Deloris Ann Simmons (later Turner, then Bauer). She married his father, Gerald Miles Turner Sr., on May 2, 1948, in Chanute, Kansas — roughly a year before Gerald Jr. was born in June 1949. At the time of the 1973 murder, Turner was 25, divorced, and the father of two small children from a prior marriage. He was living with his girlfriend Arlene Penn and their infant child at 152 Rose Avenue in Fond du Lac. He worked as a machinist for the Soo Line Railroad. He had previously rented the other side of a duplex on Amory Street that belonged to the French family (Lisa's father, Allen French). What's notably absent is that, unlike many high-profile criminal cases, there's little public detail about Turner's childhood, his parents' relationship, or any family dysfunction that may have contributed to his behavior. The trial-era psychological testimony described him as having "a cold disregard for people, mainly females," but no specific family trauma or abuse history was widely reported. In February 1975, a Fond du Lac County jury convicted Turner of second-degree murder, enticing a child for immoral purposes, and acts of sexual perversion. The jury rejected a first-degree murder charge. On February 4, 1975, he was sentenced to 38 years and six months in prison. Turner later recanted his confession and claimed innocence, but his convictions stood. The Case’s Legacy Lisa’s murder became one of Wisconsin’s most notorious crimes and earned Turner the label “Halloween Killer.” The case deeply changed Halloween practices in Fond du Lac, where many families shifted trick-or-treating to daylight hours or earlier weekend celebrations. The case also became central to later debates over Wisconsin’s handling of sexually violent offenders. Turner was released from prison in 2018 but was immediately committed to a secure state mental-health facility, where courts continued to review whether he could be released. Gerald Turner is currently 77 years old and remains in state custody at the Sand Ridge Secure Treatment Center in Mauston, Wisconsin. In July 2025, a judge denied Turner’s bid for a new probable cause hearing, allowing the state’s commitment process to proceed toward the upcoming trial. Beyond the murder of Lisa Ann French, Gerald Turner has been connected to several other alleged and confirmed offenses. Before the 1973 murder, Turner had sexually molested a 15-year-old babysitter but was never prosecuted for it. During prison interviews, Turner admitted to sexual encounters with 10 juvenile victims (some as young as two years old) and 14 women, many of whom he said he raped. He was returned to prison after authorities found hardcore child pornography in his possession. In 1998, his parole officer discovered hundreds of pornographic images on a computer hard drive in his halfway house room. In 2003, Turner returned to prison for an additional 15½ years. Three women testified that he raped and beat them during this period. Also, while on parole, he attempted to rent serial killer movies on three occasions and reportedly took a knife after his parole officer. In 2025, a judge ruled that Gerald Turner was not entitled to another probable cause hearing. The state wants to have him committed as a sexual predator. In May 2026, a trial date was set for January 19, 2027. Did he snatch Lisa French on Halloween due to opportunity, or was the Evil that surrounded him at its most powerful, and goaded him into the unspeakable? Had he been stalking her, even from a distance, when he rented the duplex her father owned? Then there are other crimes, which no doubt have a definite flavor of satanism and ritual sacrifice. An Etruscan bronze figurine depicting Sleep (Hypnos) and Death (Thanatos) carrying away Sarpedon after he was slain by Patroclus during the Trojan War.
Shadows Over Perugia: Panic, Occultism, and the Murder of Meredith Kercher
A Setting for Ritual Murder Perugia is an ancient Etruscan city that sits in the heart of the Italian region of Umbria. The Etruscan civilization was active from 900 B.C. to 27 B.C., when it was absorbed by the Roman Empire. Recent archaeological evidence indicates the Etruscans practiced human sacrifice, specifically in foundation rituals and funerary contexts. The discovery of a full-term male infant skeleton with signs of defleshing in Marzabotto (ancient Kainua) provides the first solid physical evidence of a foundation sacrifice to consecrate a temple wall. The Marzabotto infant was buried with ritual objects near a sacred wall, indicating a blood offering to appease deities and ensure agricultural fertility or spiritual transition. Evidence from Tarquinia suggests systematic human sacrifice around 500 B.C., where victims were often lower-class individuals or captured enemies. Many Greek and Roman sources accused the Etruscans of barbaric human sacrifice. These accounts have been confirmed by osteological and archaeological analysis that support the existence of these rituals. The central city is known for the University of Perugia, which was founded in 1308. The city was a stronghold of Freemasonry during the 19th century. This was the setting for the case of Meredith Kercher, who was murdered in 2007. Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito were accused in connection with her death, which occurred after a night of partying while people were still wearing vampire costumes. The case became international tabloid fodder, but it was rarely framed as a Halloween murder. Kercher was born in South London to a British journalist father and an Indian-born mother. She had three older siblings. She was murdered on Halloween eve and All Saints' Day. The dates are still given, but mention of the significance of the date is missing. The Halloween party is now a "dinner". The two late-20s Italian women who rented the room with Kercher and Knox are barely mentioned, not named, and not interviewed since 2008. Also scrubbed were Sollecito's Halloween Facebook photos. Italian prosecutor assigned to the case, Giuliano Mignini, came right out of the box with an elaborate scenario that the murder was the result of a satanic sex orgy ritual that turned homicidal when Kercher started screaming. Unfortunately, Mignini's version was easily discredited. Also, Mignini had already been labelled a "conspiracy theorist" with similar handling of the "Monster of Florence" serial killings investigation. Some believe Giuliano Mignini purposely claimed “satanists did it” but presented doubtful evidence, making it easy for Knox and Sollecito’s family attorney to obtain a gag order on any further reference to an occult motivation for the crime. In late 2007, Italy was gripped by a heightened wave of well-deserved alarm over crimes connected to occult rituals. Perugia, Italy, has been the center of several high-profile cases and broader cultural phenomena involving satanic activity. The sensationalized 1998 ritual killings by the "Beasts of Satan" heavy-metal cult were still fresh in the national psyche. In Perugia—a city with a history of dark rumors and cult activity—lead prosecutor Giuliano Mignini had already made a name for himself pursuing theories of sacrificial black masses in the unsolved "Monster of Florence" serial killings. When a gruesome murder occurred on the threshold between Halloween night and All Saints' Day, Mignini saw the handiwork of the occult. Scene of the crime (inset) Kercher, Knox and Sollecito c.2007
The Crime Scene on Halloween Night
On the evening of October 31, 2007, 21-year-old British exchange student Meredith Kercher watched The Notebook with her friend Sandra Purton before returning around 9:00 PM to the upper apartment at Via della Pergola 7. She rented it with 20-year-old American student Amanda Knox, Filomena Romanelli, and Laura Mezzetti. Both Romanelli and Mezzetti were Italian law students in their late twenties. Mezzetti was away at her family's home in Montefiascone during the weekend when Kercher was killed some time between 9 p.m. and midnight on All Saints' Day. Amanda Knox arrived the morning of November 2 with her boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito. They found the front door open, a shattered window, blood in the bathroom, and believed a burglary had taken place. They attempted to open the locked door to Kercher's room but couldn't. In the meantime, two phones were found the same morning the body was discovered. Around 11:00 a.m., a neighbor, Elisabetta Biscarini, found one phone ringing in her garden, about half a mile from the cottage, and called the Postal Police. About an hour later, around 12:00 p.m., a second ringing phone was found in the same garden. The phones were traced to Meredith Kercher, which is what prompted the police to go to the cottage, where they found Knox and Sollecito already present. The police forced open Meredith’s locked bedroom door. Inside lay a horrific scene: Meredith's body was on the floor, mostly hidden under a duvet, naked from the waist down. She had been forced to her knees, sexually assaulted at knifepoint, strangled, and stabbed three times in the neck. This on its own might not seem important; however, seen through an occult lens, it could have been purposeful. "The Druids practiced what was known as the Threefold Death, in which the individual dies at the same time in three ways, either by drowning, hanging (or strangulation), wounding (throat cutting), or head injuries. The Celts were known for their fascination with the number three. The intent was to ensure maximum bloodshed to appease the gods." "It is something I never hope to see again," Sollecito told reporters the following day. "There was blood everywhere, and I couldn't take it all in. My girlfriend (Knox) was crying and screaming, 'How could anyone do this?'" Over the following days, a series of leaks from the police suggested that not only had Knox participated in the murder, but she had instigated it, because there was bad blood between her and 21-year-old Meredith Kercher following a series of arguments about Knox's promiscuity and her personal hygiene. A court would later be told that Knox was a "she-devil" who led her accomplices in "an unstoppable crescendo of violence". Police were under immense pressure to solve the murder, and within three days suspicion had begun to fall on Knox, whose behavior had struck police as distinctly odd when she was asked to give a witness statement. While Kercher's other friends had been distraught and tearful, Knox appeared entirely detached and showed no signs of distress, even performing cartwheels and doing the splits while she waited to be questioned. She also changed her mind about where she had been on the night of the murder – at first she said she had been at Sollecito's flat, smoking marijuana and watching a film. Then she said she was confused and might have been at the flat at the same time as Meredith. Put under pressure by police, who had discovered text messages on her phone to bar owner Diya “Patrick” Lumumba, she eventually said she had been in the flat when Kercher was murdered, and heard her scream after Lumumba went into the bedroom with her. Lumumba was a Congolese bar owner in Perugia who worked part-time with Amanda Knox at his establishment, Le Chic. He was immediately arrested on suspicion of murder, as was Sollecito, whose shoes appeared to match a bloody footprint found at the scene. But less than a fortnight later, the investigation took another incredible turn. Police announced that they were looking for a fourth suspect, a local drifter called Rudy Guede, whose DNA had been found all over the murder scene, including in a bloody fingerprint and in samples which showed he had either raped Kercher or had consensual sex with her. Guede was convicted of murder and sexual assault at a fast-track trial, while Lumumba, who had a cast-iron alibi, was released after police admitted he was entirely innocent. As of recent reports, Lumumba lives in Krakow, Poland, with his wife after leaving Italy due to the social stigma associated with the case. Police remained convinced more than one person was involved, and Knox's alibi didn't stack up. She claimed she had been at Sollecito's house on the night of the murder, but mobile phone records suggested she and Sollecito had been in the vicinity of the murder scene on the night in question, then turned their phones off for around three hours around the time the murder is thought to have been committed. Sollecito, meanwhile, said he couldn't remember whether Knox had spent that night with him or not, and several witnesses described how the couple had behaved callously after the murder, kissing, cuddling and laughing near the murder scene, then shopping for skimpy lingerie, when Sollecito reportedly told Knox: "You can put these on at home and we'll have wild sex." It also transpired that before police had arrived at the house to find the body, Knox had been there and had a shower despite telling friends the bathroom was bloodstained. Both suspects also had a darker side – Knox had once written a short story about rape, which she had posted on the internet, and Sollecito had an obsession with knives and swords and collected Japanese manga comics, known for their violence and rape fantasies. But the vital breakthrough came two months later, when DNA tests on a metal clip from a bra that had been torn off Kercher during the violent attack yielded a sample of Sollecito's DNA, proving that he had been at the scene. Investigators recovered browser searches for "bleach" and "how to clean up blood" on Sollecito's computer around the time of the murder. DNA evidence also began to close the net around Knox. A kitchen knife taken from a drawer in Sollecito's kitchen had Kercher's DNA on the tip and Knox's DNA on the handle. Police were convinced they had found the murder weapon. Knox's DNA was also found to be mixed with Kercher's in a bloodstained wash basin at the house, suggesting Knox had washed Miss Kercher's blood off her hands in the sink. But after an 11-month trial, the reason for the murder remained an enigma. Having initially claimed the motive was sexual, the prosecution suggested it may have been a revenge attack by Knox, who "harbored hatred" for Kercher, who had criticized her. Meanwhile, Rudy Guede changed his story and said that Knox was at the house and murdered Kercher in a row over money. The forensic trail left in the wake of Meredith Kercher’s tragic death paints a chilling, highly calculated picture:
A translation from a judge who oversaw the first trial that ended in a guilty verdict was: It appears he believes that Guede, Knox, and Sollecito all murdered her together, although he was a bit vague. The general consensus from the pro-guilt camp seems to be that Knox and Sollecito restrained or otherwise engaged in a physical confrontation with Kercher while Guede stabbed her. Kercher crime scene photo
The "Satanic Orgy" Theory
The gruesome discovery shattered Perugia's quiet image. Within four days, Police Chief Arturo de Felice and Prosecutor Mignini made an explosive announcement that sent shockwaves across Italy: Meredith had been killed during a drug-fueled, ritualistic "satanic" group sex session after refusing to participate. To Mignini, the timing of the murder on Halloween, combined with dark online posts, painted a textbook picture of an occult sacrifice. Some critics claimed that calling the crime ritualistic without solid evidence allowed the defense attorneys to get a gag order issued stopping reference to Halloween, vampires, and satanic rite. Some even thought he had purposely gone this route. This hints at controlled opposition. As the legal battle stretched through years of trials and appeals, much of the initial "satanic" framing was quietly scrubbed or downplayed by the court to avoid a mistrial based on prejudice. References to photos of Sollecito in vampire drag vanished from public focus, and broader questions about the culture of occultism in Perugia were swept aside. One would think it was to safeguard the legal proceedings against Knox and Sollecito, but was this mostly done to run cover for those practicing ritual sacrifice in Perugia and the town’s reputation? Knox and Sollecito were initially convicted, but years of appeals exposed mishandling of forensic evidence by Perugia police—eventually leading to their complete exoneration by Italy's highest court. In 2014, it was reported that Amanda Knox' ex-lover Raffaele Sollecito was waiting for the outcome of his retrial for the 2007 murder; it seemed all along what he was seeking was a foreign girlfriend who could save him by marrying him for a green card. According to Italian media, Sollecito has been getting hot and heavy with University of Verona student and part-time model Greta Menegaldo. Sollecito attempted to woo Idaho woman Kelsey Kay over the Internet and then in person in the hopes that she would marry him, granting him citizenship in the U.S. and a potential way out of facing justice should he be found guilty in the retrial. He also proposed the same scheme to his former lover Knox, but was rebuffed, and to an Australian woman who was identified as yet another of his online pen pals. Sollecito still lives in Italy and works as a software engineer. Whether Meredith Kercher fell victim to an opportunistic predator or a chaotic escalation on Halloween night, the legal circus surrounding her death remains forever intertwined with the well-founded suspicion of a satanic ritual gone wrong. Monster of Florence crime scene photo
The Monster of Florence
Besides the Kercher murder case, Mignini also pursued the "Monster of Florence" serial killer cases, claiming a satanic sect was involved in murders and the storage of body parts for black masses. This killer claimed 16 victims between 1968 and 1985. They were usually young couples secluded in search of privacy, in wooded areas during new moons. Different weapons were used, and in half of the cases a large portion of the skin surrounding sexual organs was excised from the bodies of the female victims, and in some instances skin from their breasts. Journalist Mario Spezi coined the moniker "Monster of Florence". It was not until the Foggi–De Nuccio murders in 1981 that the police realized the killings were connected. A newspaper article about the Gentilcore–Pettini murder from 1974 caused the police to perform a ballistics test and confirm the same gun had been used in both murders. An anonymous tip also led to the connection of a murder from 1968. With the use of computer analysis and anonymous tips, a new suspect, Pietro Pacciani, was found. Pacciani had been convicted both for rape and domestic abuse of his two daughters, and for the 1951 murder of a man who had relations with his ex-girlfriend, for which he served thirteen years in prison. Anti-Monster task force chief Ruggero Perugini found incriminating evidence, such as similarities between the 1951 murder and the Monster killings. Due to appeals, Pacciano was granted a new trial, but he died in 1998. Mario Vanni, Giancarlo Lotti, and Giovanni Faggi were tried as Pacciano's accomplices. Their group was known as The Snack Buddies. In 2001, Giuttari, by now chief inspector for the Investigative Group for Serial Crimes, announced that the crimes were connected to a satanic cult allegedly active in the Florence area. In his testimony, Lotti had spoken of a doctor who had hired Pacciani to commit the murders and collect the genitalia of the women for use in rituals. Pacciani and Vanni frequented Salvatore Indovino, a self-styled occultist and fortune teller originally from Catania, at a farmhouse located in the countryside of San Casciano, where, according to testimonies, orgies and rites took place. During the searches carried out by the State Police at Pacciani's home, at least three books linked to black magic and Satanism were found. This esoteric trail is also linked to the large sums of money that Pacciani came into possession of during the years of the crimes, which gave rise to the idea that the "snack buddies" acted on behalf of personalities who remained unknown. The checks carried out by the State Police highlighted that Pacciani, before the crimes attributable to the Monster of Florence, was of modest means and had not inherited assets that could justify the sums of money considered for the most part out of league for a simple farmer like him. Based on Lotti's statements regarding a doctor as one of the instigators, Michele Giuttari and Gabriella Carlizzi speculated that a pharmacist, Francesco Calamandrei, and a deceased physician from Perugia, Francesco Narducci, had been involved in the secret society ordering Pacciani and the others. Calamandrei was put on trial while Narducci's body was exhumed. Narducci, a young doctor from a bourgeois family of Perugia, disappeared while on board his boat at Lake Trasimeno and was found dead in the lake a few days later on October 13, 1985, a month after the Monster's last double crime. Identification was handled by unorthodox means, and burial was hastened according to magistrate Giuliano Mignini. In 2001, a telephone interception during an anti-usury investigation made references to the Monster of Florence and a satanic cult. In 2018, the esoteric lead, and in particular the direct involvement of Narducci in the murders of the Monster of Florence, resurfaced during the investigation into the disappearance of Rossella Corazzin in the Belluno area in 1975. The story originates from some statements by Angelo Izzo, one of the perpetrators of the Circeo massacre. Joseph Bevilacqua (1935-2022) was suspected of being the Monster of Florence
In 2017, journalist Francesco Amicone conducted an investigation on his own that led him to find a connection between the Monster of Florence and the Zodiac Killer cases. Amicone based his research also on the hypothesis of a possible connection between Zodiac and water proposed by Robert Graysmith in the book Zodiac.
Amicone's suspect was Joseph "Joe" Bevilacqua (1935-2022), born in Totowa, New Jersey. Bevilacqua had a 20-year military career when he retired from the U.S. Army to move to Florence in July 1974. As an ABMC officer and then superintendent, Bevilacqua lived and worked at the Florence American Cemetery and Memorial, near the last Monster's crime scene, from 1974 to 1988. In 1994, he testified at the Pacciani trial. Bevilacqua denied knowing Pacciani at the time. However, in 2018, Amicone revealed to the detectives in charge of the Monster case that he had admitted to having known Pacciani since the 80s. This contradiction was then confirmed by Bevilacqua himself. According to Amicone, Bevilacqua may have been "Ulysses", an American cited by Mario Vanni as the real "Monster" in 2003, during a conversation in prison with his friend Lorenzo Nesi. During a phone call in 2017, Bevilacqua implied his responsibility in both the Monster of Florence and the Zodiac Killer cases, agreeing to Amicone's request to get a lawyer and turn himself in, before he later changed his mind. During the meetings in 2017, Bevilacqua told Amicone he was an undercover U.S. Army Criminal Investigation Command (CID) investigator operating in California at the time of Zodiac's activities in 1969 and 1970, and participated in the CID inquiry on the Khaki Mafia, which involved William O. Wooldridge (the then Sergeant Major of the Army), other Army sergeants, and firms from Los Angeles and the San Francisco Bay Area as well as in Reno, Nevada. Amicone claimed to have solved the four Zodiac ciphers, revealing Bevilacqua's name. According to Amicone's investigation, Bevilacqua might have had access to the case file of the 1968 double murder near Florence, where bullets and shell casings had been improperly stored, and replaced the pieces of evidence with spent cartridges shot by the gun he would use in the Monster's homicides to link his future crimes to those murders for which he had an alibi. Italian authorities collected Bevilacqua's DNA in late 2020. In 2021, at the request of Florence assistant district attorney Luca Turco, the Bevilacqua case started by Amicone's statements and his journalistic investigation was dismissed. Bevilacqua died in 2022 in Sesto Fiorentino. In 2025, a source from the medical staff where Bevilacqua was hospitalized in Florence said he was the Monster of Florence and that he killed his first wife. In November 2023, Amicone stated that Bevilacqua's DNA profile was sent to the authorities that investigate the Zodiac case. The investigation would have been started by the California law enforcement departments in charge of the Zodiac case after having received Bevilacqua's DNA profile from Amicone in late 2023. The existence of such an investigation has neither been confirmed nor denied by the authorities so far. The 1999 novel Hannibal, the 2001 film adaptation, and the 2013 television adaptation have all used the Monster case as the basis for a subplot of the scenes set in Florence. Thomas Harris visited Florence and attended Pacciani's trial while researching the book. In the third season of the television series, it is implied that Hannibal Lecter himself (played by Mads Mikkelsen) was the Monster. Beasts of Satan group picture, including future victims
The Beasts of Satan Cult
In a separate, confirmed criminal case, the Beasts of Satan was a satanic cult and heavy metal collective active in northern Italy. Members, including leader Nicola Sapone, were convicted of multiple ritual murders, including the killings of teenagers Fabio Tollis and Chiara Marino in 1998. The group was linked to drug-fueled rituals, and police discovered satanic paraphernalia and notebooks detailing their activities. This case contributed to police concerns about organized satanic groups in the region. The perception of satanic activity in Italy, including Perugia, led to significant law enforcement responses. The Vatican’s Squadra Anti Sette (anti-sect squad) was established to combat devil worship, with priests assisting police in deciphering crime scenes involving occult symbols. The allegations of ritual abuse and desecration include the break-in at the Kercher murder house, where satanic items like candles and knives were found. Other Cases There are other cases that at first blush do not appear to be a planned ritual sacrifice carried out by a satanic coven. Yet in cases involving alleged witchcraft or Vodou, investigators and witnesses have sometimes described occult killings as possessing a momentum of their own—as though the violence continues long after the first step has been taken. There was the October 2010 Halloween party shooting in River Oaks, where a teenage girl was reportedly shot while speaking with a friend outside her parents’ home. The suspected shooter was a boy she had dated. She had recently received an acceptance letter from Harvard. Some might call it the demon of jealousy. Its symptom: paranoid delusion. And in Napa Valley in 2004, three women returned home after a quiet Halloween spent handing out candy. Around 1 a.m., Lauren Meanza awoke to the sound of thumping. Upstairs, she discovered her housemates had been stabbed to death. The killer was later identified as the fiancé of one of the women’s friends. According to reports, he had acted on a paranoid belief that he had to kill Adriane Insogna—or his girlfriend would leave him. These are only a few of the stories attached to the night when, according to legend, the veil between worlds is thinnest. So lock the doors. Watch the shadows. And keep your cats indoors. Tonight, we’re going to ask what really happens when Halloween brings out the worst in people—and whether every monster we meet is entirely human. The murder of Peter Fabiano seemed to be without motive c.1957
The Trick-or-Treat Murder – Peter Fabiano
On Halloween night in 1957, Peter Fabiano, a 35-year-old hairstylist and former Marine, had already gone to bed with his wife, Betty, when the doorbell rang. It was nearly 11 p.m.—far too late, Peter thought, for a child to be trick-or-treating. Still, he got up, walked downstairs, and picked up the bowl of leftover candy. A moment later, Betty heard a man’s deep voice. Then came a single, deafening pop. The sound woke Betty’s daughter, Judy Solomon. When they reached the front door, they found Peter collapsed and bleeding heavily from a gunshot wound to the chest. Judy ran to a police officer who lived nearby, and Peter was rushed to Sun Valley Hospital. He was pronounced dead shortly after arriving. A teenage boy who happened to be outside told police he had seen a car speeding away from the neighborhood. No shell casing was found. Nothing had been stolen, despite the Fabianos’ ownership of two prosperous beauty salons. At first, the killing looked like a gang hit. Police discovered that Peter had once been convicted of bookmaking in 1948, when he worked as a bartender in Los Angeles. Because illegal betting was sometimes connected to organized crime, detectives considered the possibility that he had been marked for death. But the lead quickly collapsed. Peter had no known ties to any criminal syndicate, and his record was otherwise clean. His family insisted he had no enemies. So investigators began looking more closely at the people closest to him. A Friendship Turns Dark Peter and Betty had met in the 1940s, when Betty was a divorced mother of two. They married in New York, and he worked as a truck driver; then they moved to Los Angeles the year before Peter’s death. Betty operated one salon, while Peter operated another, and contemporaneous accounts described the couple as successful and financially comfortable. But their marriage had begun to fracture. During a separation, Betty moved in with Joan Rabel, a 40-year-old photographer, ex–hair salon employee, and lesbian from Philadelphia, or at least that’s the birthplace she listed on a 1948 passenger manifest for a ship traveling from Honolulu to Los Angeles. Like Pizer, Rabel had concealed her lesbianism in two failed marriages. Untethered, the women formed a powerful bond. The relationship between Betty and Rabel was more than a close friendship. There is little detail of what transpired between the two women. The Los Angeles Times described the women’s relationship as “abnormal.” (That was about as close to printing the word homosexual as a major newspaper would come in 1957.) Suffice to say Peter was threatened. When Betty and Peter reconciled, he demanded that Betty end the relationship completely. She agreed and returned home. Rabel was devastated. To police, she denied any involvement in Peter’s murder and claimed she had been home that night. But her account began to unravel when her friend Margaret Barrett reported that Rabel had borrowed her car on Halloween. Rabel claimed she had driven only a few miles. But the odometer showed that the car had traveled approximately 37 miles—enough to make the round trip from Rabel’s West Hollywood home to the Fabiano residence in Sun Valley. Investigators also said the vehicle matched the description given by the teenage witness and contained dirt resembling soil found outside the Fabiano home. Rabel was arrested on November 13, though she was later released on bail. Then detectives received an anonymous tip. The Woman Behind the Gun The tip led investigators to a storage locker at a downtown Los Angeles department store. Inside, they found a .38-caliber Smith & Wesson revolver containing one remaining bullet. Ballistics tests identified it as the weapon used to kill Peter Fabiano. The gun had been purchased from a Pasadena shop by a woman who claimed she needed it for protection. She had bought only two bullets. Her name was Goldyne Pizer. When questioned, she confessed to shooting him. After Betty, Rabel seduced Pizer. According to federal census data, Pizer was born in Rockford, Illinois, the daughter of German immigrants. By 1940, she’d moved to Los Angeles and taken up work as a medical secretary. On October 29, 1944 (almost exactly 13 years before killing Peter), she had married Herbert Krome, a pharmacist at the Naval hospital. They soon got divorced, leaving room for her to indulge her then-taboo proclivities with women. Pizer, 42, lived alone and had never met Peter Fabiano; in fact, she had never even seen him. Pizer told detectives that Rabel had spent months describing Peter as a vile and dangerous man who abused his wife, mistreated his stepdaughter and employees, and wanted to destroy everyone around him. According to Pizer, Rabel’s accusations became the center of nearly every conversation. “She painted him as a vile, evil man,” Pizer said. Peter’s widow and stepdaughter denied the allegations. But Rabel had convinced Pizer that Peter’s death was the only way to stop the supposed abuse. Pizer later said Rabel had placed her under “a hypnotic spell.” One writer gave Rabel a more theatrical name: “Svengali in a skirt.” The two women considered several methods, including poisoning and stabbing. Eventually, they settled on murder by gunshot. Rabel helped Pizer obtain the weapon and gave her money to buy it. On Halloween night, she drove Pizer to the Fabiano home. They waited nearby until the lights went out. Then Pizer approached the house alone. She rang the doorbell. When Peter opened the door, she raised the revolver and fired once into his chest. She ran back to the car, and Rabel sped away. Betty and Judy had believed there were two people at the door—possibly two men, with one disguised as a woman. They had heard the voices through the house and mistaken the arrangement entirely.
The Trial
After the murder, Pizer said Rabel told her, “Forget you ever knew me.” Pizer initially pleaded not guilty and not guilty by reason of insanity, maintaining that she was impressionable and had acted only to please her friend. One psychiatrist later described her state of mind in chilling terms: Pizer believed she had saved Joan Rabel from an evil person. Rabel continued to deny responsibility. During the proceedings, reporters described her as stony-faced, sometimes wearing a strange, persistent smile. Because the case involved two women in an intimate and socially taboo friendship, psychiatrists were asked to examine whether they were mentally fit to stand trial. Newspaper coverage used euphemisms such as “abnormal” to protect their reading audience. The exact nature of the women’s relationships remained unclear. Police called the motive “jealousy,” while tabloids hinted that the friendship between Betty and Rabel—and the hostility Peter showed toward Rabel—may have involved more than platonic affection. Whatever passed between them, the details were never fully revealed. Before the trial began, both women changed their pleas and admitted guilt to reduced charges of second-degree murder. Each was sentenced to five years to life in prison. Neither served a life sentence. Goldyne Pizer was eventually released and remained in Los Angeles. In 1971, she was made an officer of the Miracle Mile chapter of the Professional Women’s Club. Pizer died at the age of 83 in 1998. Joan Rabel was also released. She was born Joan Bessie Takiff to Lithuanian Jewish immigrants in 1915. She married Robert Lee Loper in 1935. The marriage ended very quickly, and she married Adolph Rabel in 1936. At the time of the murder, she had three prior arrests for burglary and for violating the Alcoholic Beverage Control Act. The intervening years between her conviction and release are vague, but she is listed as living with Marie Doak, a woman 14 years older than her. She died in 2012 at the age of 96. Betty Fabiano sold the beauty businesses and lived until 1999. She was never accused of participating in the murder, and no public evidence established that she knew what Rabel and Pizer were planning. But the unanswered questions remain. Was Peter Fabiano simply the victim of a jealous former friend? Was Pizer manipulated by someone who understood exactly how vulnerable she was? Or did the strained relationships among all three women conceal a darker story that never reached the courtroom? In Sun Valley, the case became known as the “trick-or-treat murder.” And ever since, the sound of a late-night doorbell on Halloween has carried a more sinister meaning. Martha Moxley
The Murder of Martha Elizabeth Moxley
On Mischief Night, 1975, a girl walked home across a quiet lawn in Belle Haven and never arrived. The golf club that killed her came from the house next door. Half a century later, no one has been held to account. Martha Elizabeth Moxley was fifteen, a California girl newly settled in Greenwich. Her family had chosen Belle Haven for its gates and guards: a pocket of Long Island Sound wealth, CEOs and the politically connected, three acres and a view of the water. She was a sophomore at Greenwich High, straight-A, easy to like, voted Best Personality in junior high. She took ballet and piano, played sports, and kept a sometime boyfriend. Across the street lived the Skakels. Rushton Skakel chaired Great Lakes Carbon, the company his family had built. His sister Ethel was the widow of Robert F. Kennedy. The house held seven children, six boys and a girl, ages nine to nineteen. Their mother, Anne, had died of cancer in 1973. Rushton was often away, and when he was home, he drank and could be harsh, especially with Michael. Privilege and trouble lived under the same roof. Michael, born September 19, 1960, struggled in school — dyslexia, undiagnosed until adulthood — and had been drinking since he was thirteen. His brother Tommy, two years older, was said to flare into anger; a childhood fall from a car had left him with a head injury and, by seventeen, a psychiatric history. Both brothers wanted Martha. Tommy pressed. She brushed him off more often than not, and she was not interested in Michael at all. She was, at most, ambivalent about Tommy. October 30 was Mischief Night, the evening before Halloween, when kids egged houses and rang doorbells. Martha had been grounded, but the next day was a school holiday, so her mother, Dorthy, let her out on a 9:30 curfew. She met friends, among them Helen Ix and Jeffrey Byrne, and drifted toward the Skakel house. The Skakel children had been taken to dinner by Kenneth Littleton, a live-in tutor who had started that very day. Around nine, the groups met in a family car, music on. At 9:30, two older Skakel brothers said they needed the car to drive their cousin Jimmy Terrien home. Martha, Helen, Jeffrey, and Tommy got out. On the lawn, Tommy and Martha flirted. Helen saw Tommy push her down and fall on top of her, then left with Jeffrey. Tommy and Martha were the last of the group still outside. About 9:45, the housekeeper thought she heard something and sent Littleton to walk the grounds. He found nothing and went back to The French Connection on television. Across the street, Dorthy was painting a window frame when she heard a commotion. She looked out and saw nothing. Martha missed curfew. By 3 a.m. Dorthy had sent her son looking and started calling. Helen said she had last seen Martha with Tommy. The Skakels said she was not there. At 3:45 Dorthy called the police and gave them a description: five-foot-five, 120 pounds, long blonde hair, blue eyes, blue parka, dungarees. In the morning Dorthy went to the Skakel door. Michael answered, home on a school day, looking hung over. He said he did not know where Martha was. They checked an RV on the property where the kids sometimes gathered. Empty. At 12:30, Martha’s friend Sheila, cutting through the Moxley yard, found the body face down under a stand of pines. The pants had been pulled to the knees. The skull was crushed. Something sharp had been driven through the neck. A trail of blood ran from the driveway to the trees. Nearby lay three pieces of a Toney Penna 6-iron, the head matted with blood. The grip was gone. Blunt trauma had killed her. The neck wound may have come after death. The shaft had broken from the force of the blows. The medical examiner put death between 9:30 p.m. and 5:30 a.m. There was no sign of sexual assault. An expert later consulted by Greenwich police, working from the autopsy, barking dogs, and the sounds Dorthy heard, placed the attack near 10 p.m. When Littleton came home from teaching that day, fifteen or twenty men from Great Lakes Carbon were already in the house. He was told to take Tommy, Michael, John, and Jimmy to a Skakel place in Windham, New York. They left Saturday morning. Two days after the murder, police found a set of Toney Penna clubs in a garage on the Skakel property. The 6-iron was missing. The grips were labeled with Anne Skakel’s name — the very section missing from the pieces in the Moxley yard. Martha’s funeral drew five hundred people to First Lutheran Church on November 4. Police watched the crowd. On November 15, Rushton brought Michael, Tommy, Jimmy, and Julie in to give statements. Tommy said he had last seen Martha walking home around 9:30, then worked on a paper about Lincoln before joining Littleton for the movie. Michael said he had gone to the Terriens’ and returned about 11, then gone to bed. Every detective in Greenwich was put on the case. More than three hundred people were questioned, some five times or more. The focus settled on Tommy, the last person known to have been with her. He failed one polygraph and passed another. Teachers said no Lincoln paper had been assigned. Rumors ran so hot the local paper ran an editorial against them. In January 1976, on advice of counsel, Rushton stopped the family from talking to police and hired a lawyer for Tommy. Neighbors muttered that money and a Kennedy connection were shielding someone. Police denied it. Tommy later told a reporter he had been grilled for hours, followed in marked and unmarked cars, and even stopped on his eighteenth birthday. On May 21, 1976, police sought a warrant for him. The state’s attorney refused it for lack of evidence. Other names were checked and set aside. Martha’s boyfriend had stayed home. A graduate student next door was cleared. Littleton was looked at in 1976, after the Skakels dismissed him and after a Nantucket burglary arrest cost him a teaching job. He had serious mental illness and a drinking problem; his mother said the case ruined the family. Nothing tied him to the killing. By the end of 1976 the file was inactive. Michael, though, kept behaving like a boy with something he could not hold. In a barbershop in the spring of 1976 he said, “I’m going to kill him,” and when his sister Julie rebuked him he answered, “Why not? I did it before.” In 1977, the family driver, Larry Zicarelli, was taking him into New York after a fight with his father. Michael said he had done something very bad and would have to kill himself or leave the country. Stopped on the Triborough Bridge, he jumped out twice and ran for the rail. Pulled back the second time, he told Zicarelli that if he knew what Michael had done, he would never speak to him again. Rushton is said to have told a friend that Michael wished he could know for certain whether he had killed Martha. Both later denied it. In March 1978, a DUI was bargained into treatment. Michael spent 1978 to 1980 at Elan, a therapeutic school in Poland Spring, Maine, known for confrontation and humiliation. After he ran away, another student, Gregory Coleman, was set to guard him. At a general meeting, Joe Ricci announced they would get to the bottom of why Michael had murdered Martha Moxley. Former student Michael Wiggins later said that each denial put Michael back in a boxing ring, and that the questioning stopped only when he said, “I don’t know.” He was made to wear signs: “Confront me on why I killed Martha Moxley,” and “Please confront me on why I am a spoiled brat.” In groups, he did not quite confess. He said he had been blind drunk and was not sure what had happened. In private, the stories swung from boast to tears. Coleman would later testify that Michael said he would get away with murder because he was a Kennedy, and that a girl who refused him had her skull driven in with a golf club. John Higgins said that on a night of guard duty Michael moved from “maybe I did it” to “I must have done it” to “I did it,” and described going through the garage for a club, then running through woods and pine trees with it in his hands. Others heard only that he could not remember, that his family might have hidden him at Elan, that his brother had been fooling around with a girl he wanted. The case slept. Some investigators had already shifted their suspicion from Tommy to Michael. In 1991, reporter Leonard Levitt published a piece in the Greenwich Times on the investigation’s failures, including the fact that police had not searched the Skakel house even after the club was traced there. The state reopened the file under Frank Garr. Levitt and Garr later co-wrote Conviction, arguing the family’s guilt. In 1992, police persuaded Littleton’s ex-wife to record calls and then stage a sting: in a bugged hotel room she told him he had confessed during a blackout. He had not. He grew confused but did not confess. She later said she lied because police promised Dorthy closure, and that she waited years to tell him the confession had been invented. He failed two polygraphs and still insisted he had not heard Martha’s name until the day after she vanished. Rushton hired Sutton Associates to investigate for the family. Under that questioning, both brothers changed their stories. Tommy admitted he had not watched Martha walk home at 9:30. He said they had stayed on the lawn in consensual mutual masturbation until about 10, and then she left. Michael still claimed the trip to the Terriens’, but added that around 11:30 he had gone out peeping in windows, climbed a tree in the Moxley yard, masturbated, and run home past the place where the body was found. One Sutton investigator, Jim Murphy, came away convinced Tommy had done it. In Levitt’s account, Tommy was near tears in a 1993 interview when his lawyer shut it down. The Sutton report leaked in 1994 to Levitt and to Dominick Dunne, who passed a copy to Mark Fuhrman. Fuhrman’s Murder in Greenwich (1998) named Michael. Dunne had already published A Season in Purgatory (1993), a novel in which a Michael-like figure was the killer. Publicity and the changed statements produced a one-person grand jury in September 1998. More than forty witnesses testified, including Littleton under immunity and former Elan students. A $50,000 reward was offered. In January 2000, the grand jury found enough to charge Michael. He was arrested on January 19, age forty, married to Marjorie Sheridan, with a son born in 1999. The marriage did not survive the arrest. Released on $500,000 bond, he told Dorthy at arraignment, “I feel your pain, but you’ve got the wrong guy.” She was not moved. Because he had been a minor in 1975, the case began in juvenile court, where the maximum was four years. On January 31, 2001, Judge Maureen Dennis moved it to Superior Court: there was no institution suited to a forty-year-old if he were adjudicated delinquent. Trial opened May 8, 2002. There was no direct evidence. The state’s theory was jealous rage after Michael saw Martha with Tommy. Her diary went in to show the triangle: Tom’s hand on her knee, Michael treating her at Friendly’s, Michael accusing her of leading Tom on, her note that she really had to stop going over there. Prosecutor Susann Gill argued the relationship, her annoyance with Michael, and his later claim that she rejected him that night were the motive. Dr. Henry Lee, from the state crime lab, testified there was no one else’s blood and no foreign DNA. From photos and reports, he said the first blow likely did not knock her out, that the attacker was on top of her, that blood inside the jeans meant they were down before the beating, and that spatter fit a victim already lying down. No semen; any trace could have been lost when she was dragged some eighty feet. No defensive wounds. “No direct evidence,” he told defense lawyer Mickey Sherman, “but I have indirect evidence.” Tommy and Michael Skakel c.1970s
Andrea Shakespeare Renna, a friend of Julie Skakel’s who had been at the house, said she “knew” Michael had not gotten into the Lincoln with the others. She also said that on October 31, when she and Julie came home to news of the murder, Michael ran up saying Martha was dead and that he and Tommy had been the last to see her. Mildred Ix’s dog had barked, fixed and unmovable, toward the Moxley house for fifteen or twenty minutes around 9:45 to 10:15. Littleton repeated that he had walked the drive, that Tommy later joined him for the movie and seemed composed, and that he had never met Martha. He denied the killing. The defense pressed the 1992 sting; his ex-wife testified he had never confessed to her.
Then came the statements. The barber. Zicarelli and the bridge. Mildred Ix, who said Rushton had confided that Michael feared he had been too drunk to remember the night. Six from Elan: Chuck Seigen, Dorothy Rogers, John Higgins, Elizabeth Arnold, Alice Dunn, and Gregory Coleman. Coleman had died of an overdose in 2001; his testimony was read. He said Michael claimed he would get away with murder because he was a Kennedy, and that he had driven a girl’s head in with a golf club. Higgins gave the garage, the woods, the pines, the slide from maybe to I did it. Others heard only blackout, drink, and doubt — or that his brother had “stolen his girlfriend.” The defense answered the bridge story with a claim that the “something bad” was sleeping in, or hugging, his dead mother’s dress. Michael told reporters his father had made the children kneel for hours praying she would live. Two later acquaintances, Michael Meredith and Andrew Pugh, said he had denied the murder but placed himself in the tree, masturbating, and in one version watching Tommy cross the lawn. Tapes made with Richard Hoffman for a memoir put him at the cousin’s house, then home, restless, spying on a woman on Walsh Lane, then deciding Martha liked him, and he would get a kiss. He climbed the tree, masturbated, climbed down, and felt he should not cross a dark oval on the lawn. He threw rocks into it — “Come on motherfucker, I’ll kick your ass” — and ran, afraid someone had seen him. In the morning, when Dorthy asked if he had seen Martha, he felt panic: had they seen him the night before? The state rested May 21. Prosecutor Benedict cast the tree story as a cover in case semen was ever found. A multimedia close played Michael’s voice over images of the crime, ending on Dorthy at the door and his hope that nobody had seen him. The defense opened with the alibi. Rushton Jr. and Jimmy Terrien said Michael had ridden with them, leaving Belle Haven about 9:30 and the Terrien house about 11. David Skakel described distressed barking between 9:30 and 10. The point was to fix death at 10, inside the alibi. Andrea Renna, recalled, said her certainty now was simply “my memory.” Four former Elan students described signs and boxing-ring beatings when Michael would not admit the killing; one called it hours of torture. The argument was coercion. On the last day John Skakel said he had no independent memory of the car, only his 1975 statement that Michael had been in it, and that he had heard a noise in the mud room — where the clubs were later found — around 11:30. Retired detective James Lunney said an arrest warrant for Tommy had been drawn and rejected. Michael’s 1975 statement was read: "Terriens’, then bed about 11:15". Retired medical examiner Joseph Jachimczyk, consulted in 1975, put death at 10 p.m., give or take an hour, from digestion, rigor, curfew habits, and the dogs. The jury deliberated three and a half days and on June 7 returned guilty. Dorthy and her son John held each other in the front row. Jurors later cited the changing stories, the behavior, and the tape that put him in the yard. On August 29, 2002, he was sentenced to twenty years to life. His first words of the trial were a rambling ten-minute statement. Appeals followed for years: statute of limitations, undisclosed composite sketch and profiles of Tommy and Littleton, misconduct in closing, an edit that cut “What if someone saw me jerking off?” down to “What if someone saw me?” The appeal failed in 2006. The U.S. Supreme Court declined review. In 2003, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. published A Miscarriage of Justice in The Atlantic, asserting innocence and pointing at other suspects, Littleton among them. A bid for a new trial failed in 2007, and the state Supreme Court affirmed in 2010. In 2010, new lawyers sought habeas relief for ineffective counsel. A sentence-reduction bid and parole were denied in 2012. After a two-week habeas trial, Judge Thomas Bishop on October 23, 2013, vacated the conviction. Sherman’s work, he wrote, had been constitutionally deficient: no attention to detail, no energetic investigation, no coherent plan. Michael was released November 21, 2013, on $1.2 million bail, after eleven years. The state won reinstatement in December 2016. A retired justice shifted the court; a second reconsideration, in May 2018, vacated the conviction 4–3. The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the state’s appeal. On October 30, 2020 — forty-five years to the day — prosecutors said they would not retry. Seventeen of fifty-one potential witnesses were dead. No new forensic evidence remained. They entered a nolle. After thirteen months the case was dismissed. Michael Skakel was free. Martha’s brother said the family was at peace with the decision, and that it would never be over. He did not call Michael a devil. He thought a jealous rage, alcohol, drugs, a fifteen-year-old who may not have known what he was doing. Dorthy, who had sat through the years, still believed Michael guilty, and said the guilty verdict had given her the justice she needed. She died on August 31, 2023. David Moxley had died of a heart attack in 1988, at fifty-seven. In 2023, Michael sued Greenwich and Frank Garr for malicious prosecution, alleging they had pursued a “Kennedy cousin” while knowing likelier suspects existed. The grip of the club was never found. No one’s blood but Martha’s was at the scene. The attack was ferocious and personal, and it happened fast, in the gap after the others left and before the neighborhood settled. Tommy was the last person seen with her, and he lied about the hour on the lawn. Littleton had no clear motive and no solid tie. A stranger on Mischief Night does not explain a weapon taken from a labeled set in a family garage, or a beating with no defensive wounds and no sexual assault. Michael had the jealousy, the drink, the knowledge of the clubs, the stories that put him in the yard, and the years of remarks that sounded like a conscience trying to surface. His alibi rested on family. The Elan words may have been beaten out of him. The state, in the end, said it could not prove the case again. Someone followed her, or met her, between the Skakel lawn and the pines. Someone knew where Anne Skakel’s clubs were kept. The dark oval on the lawn, the barking dog, the missing grip — they are still there in the record, and they do not speak. Martha did not finish high school. She did not get a life beyond that night. The gates of Belle Haven closed behind a murder that, officially, no longer has a killer. Bittaker and Norris
Tool Box Killers: The Murder of Shirley Lynette Ledford
On Halloween night, 1979, sixteen-year-old Shirley Lynette Ledford was trying to get home from a party in Sunland-Tujunga. By morning, her body was lying in a bed of ivy on a stranger’s lawn. A jogger found her. She was the last girl taken by Lawrence Bittaker and Roy Norris, the pair later called the Toolbox Killers, and the only one of their five victims left where the city would have to look at her. Shirley was born March 4, 1963, in Los Angeles County, and lived in Burbank. She worked part-time as a waitress. Investigators later believed she accepted the ride because she recognized Bittaker: he had been a regular at the McDonald’s where she worked. Outside a gas station, hitchhiking after the party, she got into a silver-gray 1977 GMC van the two men had nicknamed Murder Mac. The men had met in 1977 at California Men’s Colony in San Luis Obispo. Norris was there for rape. Bittaker was there for assault with a deadly weapon, the last stop in a record that ran from juvenile theft to a near-fatal stabbing of a supermarket worker. Behind bars, they talked their way into a plan: kidnap teenage girls, one of each age from thirteen to nineteen, and leave no witnesses. Both were free by early 1979. Bittaker, working as a machinist in Burbank, bought the windowless van with Norris’s help. They soundproofed it, rigged the rear doors so they opened only from the outside, and bought a scanner for police radio. Through the spring they picked up more than twenty hitchhikers and let them go. Practice. In April they broke the lock on a fire road in the San Gabriel Mountains and replaced it with one of their own. Between June and September they killed four girls on that mountain: Lucinda Schaefer, 16; Andrea Hall, 18; and, taken together, Jackie Gilliam, 15, and Jacqueline Lamp, 13. The bodies of the first two were never found. Gilliam and Lamp were recovered months later at the bottom of a canyon. Shirley was different. They did not take her into the mountains. They drove the streets for more than an hour with her in the back, and they recorded it. The tape, about seventeen minutes of it, played in court and became the case. Norris later said the screams from the rear of the van did not stop. After roughly two hours, he strangled her with a wire coat hanger tightened with pliers. Her eyes were still open. Bittaker wanted the body left in public, to see what the papers would do. They chose a lawn in Sunland at random. Norris set her in the ivy, and they drove away. The autopsy found strangulation after extensive blunt-force trauma to the face, head, breasts, and left elbow, which had been broken, and severe internal injury. Bittaker would claim the recording was only evidence of a threesome, and that near the end Shirley had begged to be killed. The tape said otherwise. In November, Norris told an old prison acquaintance, Joseph Jackson, what they had done, including Shirley, the only victim whose body had surfaced. Jackson went to his lawyer, then to police. Hermosa Beach detective Paul Bynum matched the story to missing-girl reports and to a September 30 rape: Robin Robeck had been sprayed with Mace, dragged into a van, and released. Shown photographs, she identified Bittaker and Norris at once. On November 20, 1979, Norris was arrested for a parole violation after police watched him sell marijuana. The same day Bittaker was arrested at his Burbank motel for the Robeck rape. Robeck could not pick them out of a lineup, but the search made the lineup unnecessary. In the apartment were Polaroids of Andrea Hall and Jackie Gilliam. In the van: a sledgehammer, lead weights, a book on police frequencies, Vaseline, two necklaces later tied to victims, and the cassette. Shirley’s mother identified her daughter’s voice. The men’s voices were Bittaker’s and Norris’s. A bracelet taken from Shirley’s body was in Norris’s apartment. Both men also had Polaroids of nearly five hundred teenage girls, most taken without their knowledge at Redondo Beach, Hermosa Beach, and a Burbank high school. Shirley Ledford
Police later found sixty of those girls alive and unharmed. Nineteen others in the pictures had been reported missing. One photograph shows an unidentified young woman alone with both men, in the same kind of pose as the known dead. She has never been named. Neither man ever mentioned her.
On November 30 Norris waived his rights and, faced with the evidence, confessed in what detectives called a casual, unconcerned manner, shifting the worst of it onto Bittaker. He described the ruse: rides, marijuana, photos. Most girls refused. Four accepted and were killed; the first, Schaefer, was pulled in by force. He knew details only someone present would know: that Schaefer had left a church fellowship, that she lost a shoe as she was dragged in, that Shirley was part Hispanic, that Bittaker had already asked her out and been turned down. The bottles of acid in the motel, he said, were for the next girl. He led detectives back into the San Gabriels. Schaefer and Hall were not there. On February 9, 1980, the scattered remains of Lamp and Gilliam were found in a canyon; an ice pick was still in Gilliam’s skull. Norris pleaded guilty on March 18, 1980, to four counts of first-degree murder, one of second-degree murder, two rapes, and a robbery. On May 7, he was sentenced to forty-five years to life, eligible for parole in 2010. A probation officer called him an extreme sociopath beyond rehabilitation, compulsive in his need to inflict pain, and without remorse. Bittaker’s trial opened January 19, 1981, in Torrance, the first felony case televised in California. Prosecutor Stephen Kay told the jury they would not like Norris, but that when a murder is committed in hell, you do not get angels for witnesses. Norris testified for days. Neighbors said Bittaker had shown them photographs and played a tape of girls screaming. A cellmate, Lloyd Douglas, said Bittaker had described what he did to Gilliam and to Shirley. The defense argued Norris was the killer and Bittaker only a late confidant. Then the tape was played. More than a hundred people were in the room. Jurors and spectators wept; some left. Bittaker smiled. Kay walked out at recess in tears and told reporters the jury needed to hear what the two men had done. On the stand, Bittaker denied the Schaefer murder, claimed he had paid Hall and Gilliam to pose, and said Shirley had agreed to scream for the recorder. The jury did not believe him. On February 17, after three days, they convicted him of five first-degree murders and a long list of kidnappings, rapes, and related counts. Ninety minutes later, they voted death. He stared at them and showed nothing. On March 24, 1981, Judge Thomas Fredericks sentenced him to death, with an alternative term of 199 years and four months if the sentence were ever reduced. Appeals failed. Execution dates in 1989 and 1991 were stayed. On death row at San Quentin, he signed letters “Pliers” Bittaker, filed dozens of frivolous lawsuits, and said his only real regret was being caught. He died of natural causes on December 13, 2019, at seventy-nine. Norris, who spent years claiming he had acted out of fear and had not enjoyed the killing, was denied parole in 2019 and died of natural causes on February 24, 2020, at seventy-two. Kay still called it the worst case he ever tried. For two years afterward, he dreamed of running to the van and arriving too late. In December 1987, Paul Bynum was found dead inside his Glendale, California home with an allegedly self-inflicted gunshot wound to his head. The 39-year-old left a note that said the murders haunted him and that he feared the men might be released. His untimely death was suspicious, because at the same time he was also involved in another headline-making investigation: the McMartin Preschool Child Abuse Scandal as a PI for the defense. Before this, he investigated the 1976 case of Karen Klaas, who was raped and then strangled with a pair of pantyhose. Despite the attention the case received, since she was married to Bill Medley of the Righteous Brothers, the case went cold and stayed that way for decades. The cassette of Ledford's torture and death remains at the FBI Academy, used to train agents in what a recording of a killing actually sounds like. Halloween was the night they stopped hiding the bodies. Four girls had already vanished into the chaparral. Shirley Lynette Ledford was left on the grass, in the ivy, where a jogger would find her at first light, and where a tape would keep her voice long after Bittaker and Norris were gone.
A Demon Visits St. Francis Convent
On Halloween night in 1981, someone came through a broken window at the St. Francis Convent in Amarillo and killed a nun in her bed. The sisters who found her the next morning thought, at first, that she had simply died. Sister Tadea Benz, born Martina Benz, was seventy-six, a Franciscan and a native of Switzerland. She lived on the second floor of the Roman Catholic convent. On the morning of November 1, other nuns found her in her room, nude, under a sheet. There was a spot of blood on the pillow. Sister Bernice, reached by telephone, later explained why no one immediately called it murder: the blood was not all over the room, and it looked, at a glance, like a hemorrhage. The black eye was hidden under blood on her face. They did not uncover the body. Bernice did notice a wound on the neck. Peace Justice Elby Bartlett did not treat it as a natural death. Sister Tadea’s larynx had been crushed. He ruled the death a homicide late that Saturday. The autopsy found stab wounds, knuckle marks and other contusions to the head, abrasive injuries to the neck, and signs of external bleeding and internal trauma consistent with rape. The pathologist’s cause of death was manual strangulation. Police found a broken window in the convent’s community room, a cut screen, and a board outside. Two knives were recovered: one under the bed with a bent blade, another kitchen knife in the driveway. They took the bloody sheets the nuns had already removed from the bed, and they lifted fingerprints and palm prints from the knife blade, the headboard, and the screen. Across the street lived Johnny Frank Garrett, seventeen years old, born December 24, 1963. A witness said that on the night of the murder he had seen Garrett running from the direction of the convent. The kitchen knife in the driveway matched, in design, make, and wear, a knife later recovered from Garrett’s home. Prints at the scene were linked to him. On November 9, 1981, ten days after the killing, police arrested him. At trial, the state said he had broken in, raped Sister Tadea, and strangled her. Garrett said he had not. The jury convicted him and sentenced him to death. He was sent to death row at the Ellis Unit. What the jury did not hear was the history later assembled by doctors and by his family: regular beatings by his father and stepfathers, including a burn from a stove burner that left a permanent scar; sexual abuse, including rape by a stepfather and coercion into pornographic films by about fourteen; alcohol, amphetamines, and paint thinner introduced at home when he was ten. A mental-health expert who reviewed him described one of the most severe histories of abuse and neglect he had seen in twenty-eight years of practice, and later evaluations spoke of brain damage, chronic psychosis, and dissociative symptoms. None of that was put before the jury. He spent eleven years on death row insisting he was innocent. An execution set for January 6, 1992, was stayed after Governor Ann Richards granted a reprieve at the request of Pope John Paul II. The Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles then voted 17–0 against commuting the sentence to life. On February 11, 1992, Garrett, twenty-eight, was put to death by lethal injection. His last meal was ice cream. His last words are still disputed. He was widely quoted as thanking his family and telling the rest of the world to kiss his ass. The Texas Department of Criminal Justice record says he declined to make a final statement. The argument did not end with the execution. Around the same period, seventy-seven-year-old Narnie Bryson — also reported as Narne Box Bryson — was raped and killed similarly. Leoncio Perez Rueda pleaded guilty in that case and was sentenced to forty-five years. Garrett’s sisters, Jeana Weaver and Janet Dobbins, and appeals lawyer Jeff Blackburn came to believe Rueda belonged in the convent room as well. Blackburn stopped short of saying Garrett had never broken in or never killed the nun. He said he was convinced Garrett had not raped her, and that DNA testing, had it been available and usable, would have cleared him of that. In 2004, DNA was reported to have linked Rueda to evidence from the Benz scene, which sharpened the claim that Texas had executed the wrong man, or at least the wrong man for part of the crime. Clearing the name is another matter. District Attorney Randall Sims said any new test would require proof that the sample still existed, could still be tested, and had not been altered, plus further evidence of innocence. Blackburn doubted it would ever be settled cleanly. Attorney Jesse Quackenbush later made a documentary, The Last Word, arguing that overzealous prosecution and unused evidence should make even supporters of the death penalty uneasy. Janet Dobbins said she would still be asking in forty years. Rueda remained in prison on the Bryson sentence. Sister Tadea Benz was buried as a homicide victim. Johnny Frank Garrett was buried as her killer. Between the crushed larynx, the prints on the knife, the neighbor seen running in the dark, and a DNA result that arrived too late to be tested in front of a jury, the Halloween night at St. Francis Convent never quite closed. James Adamski
The Unsolved Case of James Adamski
James Adamski, an 18-year-old senior at Depew High School, was murdered in Lancaster, New York. On the early morning of October 31, 1982, Adamski left a Halloween costume party at the 5&23 Bar on Transit Road in Depew. He was last seen walking south on Transit Road around 3:30 a.m. after parting ways with a female companion, whom police interviewed and ruled out as a suspect. His body was discovered nearly two months later, on December 26, 1982, by rabbit hunters in a shallow grave covered with twigs and leaves off Ransom Road in Lancaster, approximately four miles from where he was last seen. This was by the railroad, and some believe whoever left him there was familiar with the area. The medical examiner determined he died from blunt force trauma to the head, likely inflicted by a baseball bat, 2x4 plank, or a tire iron. Police learned that there was an argument earlier in the night at the bar and that James and others were considerably inebriated at this point. Many of the leads the police received went cold, and no arrests were made. After the discovery of Adamski's remains, police confirmed they were comparing notes with the torture killing of a young man a few days before. "Both of the young males were repeatedly injured ... in a frenzied attack, and both of them were left in field-type areas with their clothes removed," one police source said. There was also some confusion as to the last time Adamski was seen alive since it was daylight saving time change. He was killed by "at least a dozen separate severe blows by blunt and semi-blunt objects." There was speculation if there was a ritualistic or sexual overtone to the murders. The puzzling component of this case is how James Adamski, by all accounts, was a friendly and good-natured young man. Friends and acquaintances spoke very highly of him, and there's little reason to believe he made very many enemies during his lifetime. The case remains unsolved, with police theorizing that Adamski was picked up by a stranger or acquaintance while intoxicated and killed in a vehicle before his body was dumped. Despite a thorough initial investigation and recent renewed efforts by the Lancaster Police Department and Erie County District Attorney, no arrests have been made. An $11,000 reward ($10,000 from Lancaster Police and $1,000 from Crime Stoppers Buffalo) is currently offered for information leading to an arrest. A few months later, there was another ritualistic type of murder. In 1983, teenager Richard “Ricky” Kasso Jr. was arrested for digging up a colonial-era grave in a local New York cemetery—a dark prelude to the violence that would soon shock Northport. Kasso was a peripheral figure among a loosely organized circle of local marijuana dealers who called themselves the "Knights of the Black Circle." He earned the nickname "The Acid King" for his illegal drug abuse, including LSD. The heavy-metal-fueled subculture took a fatal turn on June 16, 1984, inside the shadows of Aztakea Woods. There, 17-year-old Gary Lauwers was brutally stabbed to death by Kasso. The murder was said to be a four-hour ritual that was carried out before followers of a satanic cult, a twenty-member gathering of the Knights of the Black Circle. Present were Jimmy Troiano and Albert Quiñones. In the days following the killing, Kasso openly bragged to friends about the act, claiming satan had manifested as a black crow, its caw signifying demonic approval. When several teens refused to believe him, Kasso led them straight to Lauwers' exposed corpse before he and Troiano finally returned to bury the decomposing body in a shallow grave. It took over two weeks for anyone to break the silence. On July 1, an anonymous tip finally alerted authorities to the woods. Three days later, on July 4, 1984, police search dogs uncovered Lauwers' mutilated remains. Kasso and Troiano were arrested the following day, but justice would never reach the main perpetrator. On July 7, 1984, just two days after his arrest, a guard found Kasso in his cell dead after hanging himself from a bar by a bedsheet. Due to substantial publicity in American newspapers, three television documentaries, two films, two books, and in the lyrics of at least twenty songs of heavy metal rock musicians, Kasso is mentioned. Troiano stood trial for second-degree murder in 1985, but was ultimately acquitted—largely due to conflicting testimony from the sole remaining eyewitness, Quiñones. Liske murder house, victims and the killer
A Killer in the Family: The Story of B.J. Liske
Long before the bloody Halloween morning of 2010, William "B.J." Liske Jr. was a ticking time bomb inside his family’s Benton Township, Ohio home. Following his parents' 1995 divorce, Liske’s behavior steadily deteriorated into a chilling cycle of untreated mental illness, substance abuse, and unchecked violence. Known to stop taking his psychiatric medication while drinking and smoking marijuana, Liske was diagnosed by 2007 with bipolar schizoaffective disorder. Yet, despite being terrorized by his son, his father, William Liske Sr., refused to give up on him. The signs of danger had been mounting for over a decade:
Neighbors and friends—including family friend Mark Gradel—frequently warned William Sr. about his safety. Gradel often had to intervene during physical altercations between father and son. Neighbors even suspected Liske of injuring local pets, including Gradel’s dog, which was shot twice with a .22-caliber rifle. Despite the history of domestic violence, William Sr. invited his 24-year-old son to go hunting on October 30, 2010. After drinking heavily with friends and family, Liske was allowed to spend the night at his father’s house. In the quiet hours before dawn on October 31, 2010, Liske carried out a calculated massacre while the household slept. He first entered the bedroom of his stepbrother, Derek Griffin, bludgeoning him to death with a claw hammer to avoid making noise. Armed with a .22-caliber rifle, Liske then moved to the master bedroom, where he sexually assaulted his stepmother, Susan, before shooting her three times and shooting his father five times. At around 8:00 AM, Liske’s 16-year-old stepbrother, Devon Griffin—who had stayed elsewhere the night before—briefly stopped by to change clothes for church. Devon saw Liske loading items into William Sr.'s truck. When Liske asked how long he’d be there, Devon replied he was only changing his shirt. Unaware of the slaughter inside, Devon left for church, a delay that likely saved his life. Devon returned home at 2:00 PM. Noticing the unsettling silence, he searched the house and discovered his stepfather’s blood-soaked body in bed. Horrified, Devon ran from the house and called his aunt, Lori Morse. Morse rushed to the scene and made a frantic 911 call, telling the dispatcher: "Oh my God... He’s got to be dead," before noting that BJ Liske had a long history of threatening the family. Responding Ottawa County Sheriff’s deputies kicked in a locked bedroom door to find Derek’s bludgeoned body, completing the grisly discovery. Liske was gone, along with his father’s truck. The manhunt was swift. Hours later, Carroll County Sheriff’s deputies tracked Liske to the family’s hunting cabin in Canton, Ohio—170 miles away. Officers recovered a .22-caliber rifle, William Sr.’s wallet and cell phone, and noted blood on Liske's shoes and clothes. DNA testing later confirmed the presence of all three victims' blood on his clothing and underwear. In November 2010, Liske was indicted on six counts of aggravated murder. While in jail, a recorded phone call caught his mother, Barbara Liske, reading him a news article about the killings before telling him, "You did it, you did all this." Liske plainly responded, "Yes." After undergoing two competency evaluations, Liske was deemed fit to stand trial. On August 12, 2011, he pleaded guilty to three counts of aggravated murder to avoid the death penalty. Prior to sentencing, he offered an apology, blaming his actions on satan and his mental illness. In September 2011, Liske was sentenced to three consecutive life terms without the possibility of parole. His story came to an abrupt end on March 31, 2015, when he died by suicide in his cell at the Ross Correctional Institution in Chillicothe, Ohio. In a strange twist, one day after the Liske murder, Liske Sr.'s sister, Susan Ann Liske Dunmyer, died in a mysterious house fire that consumed a detached garage. Her husband, Timothy, was out of town. Toxicology reports and the cause of death were promised, but never published in the newspapers. Taylor Van Diest
The Rape and Murder of Taylor Van Diest
In the small, close-knit city of Armstrong, British Columbia, Halloween 2011 began with lighthearted excitement. Eighteen-year-old Taylor Van Diest dressed up as a zombie, eager to go trick-or-treating with her friends one last time before they all grew “too old.” Just ten minutes into her short walk to a friend's house, her text messages abruptly stopped. Her final, chilling text to her boyfriend revealed her mounting uneasy feeling: she was being "creeped on." When Taylor failed to arrive, frantic friends and family combed the area. Two hours later, they found her lying beside nearby railroad tracks—savagely beaten and barely breathing. She was rushed to the hospital, where she tragically succumbed to her injuries early the next morning. As Taylor lingered in her final hours, an attentive hospital nurse clipped her fingernails—a routine forensic measure that would ultimately secure the key DNA evidence needed to catch her killer. The brutal murder of a beloved girl with no known enemies sent shockwaves through the community of 5,000. Unbeknownst to residents, Taylor had crossed paths with a predator named Matthew Foerster whose violent record reached back nearly a decade:
On October 31, 2011, Foerster struck again. High on marijuana and alcohol, he spotted Taylor walking alone and followed her to a secluded spot along the tracks with the intent to rape her. When Taylor fought back and screamed, Foerster brutally struck her head with a heavy flashlight and strangled her with a shoelace before leaving her for dead. The forensic breakthrough came when DNA extracted from under Taylor’s fingernails matched the semen sample from the 2005 escort agency rape, confirming a single serial attacker was responsible. RCMP investigators released a composite sketch of the 2005 suspect based on the escort worker's original description. When the sketch circulated, residents in nearby Cherryville and Lumby recognized the face as 26-year-old Matthew Foerster, triggering over 30 tips to police. Realizing the net was closing in, 58-year-old Stephen Foerster sprang into action to protect his son once more. He quit his job as a truck driver, cleaned out Matthew's rental apartment, and bought $500 worth of stolen identification documents—including a driver's license and BCAA card—so Matthew could flee to Ontario under a false identity. Intercepted wiretaps later captured Stephen warning his son over prepaid cellphones to alter the fake Social Insurance Number and lay low because things were "hotter than a firecracker." When friends confronted Stephen about the composite sketch, he ordered them to keep quiet. The cover-up failed. On April 4, 2012, police tracked Matthew to Ontario and arrested him; Stephen was taken into custody the same day. (During a court appearance later that month, tensions boiled over when Matthew's mother, Deb Foerster, lashed out at reporters and struck a photographer with her purse outside the courthouse.) Both men ultimately faced justice:
Halloween has long been a night when the ordinary rules of the dark are set aside, yet for some it has never been a costume. On Mischief Night in 1975, Martha Moxley was beaten to death with a golf club from the house across the lawn in Greenwich. Four years later, Shirley Ledford accepted a ride after a party in Sunland and was left on a stranger’s ivy the next morning. In 1981, Sister Tadea Benz was found in her convent room in Amarillo, the window broken and the first light revealing what the sisters had briefly taken for a natural death. The dates are the same; the cities, the weapons, and the years of argument that followed are not. What they share is the way a holiday of masks and open doors can still hide a crime in plain sight, and how long the questions can outlast both the victims and the people later named as their killers.
#ShadowsofHalloween #WhentheVeilThins #SamhainOrigins #DruidSacrifices #HalloweenTrueCrime #OccultHistory #BlackCatSafety #HalloweenMythsandLegends
#SatanicPanic #ItalianTrueCrime #OccultRituals #BeastsofSatan #SquadraAntiSette #MonsterofFlorence #HalloweenCrime #ColdCaseForensics
0 Comments
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
Stories of the Supernatural PodcastStories of the Supernatural listen to episodes without commercial interruption on your browser or download the mp3 file
Marlene
|





















RSS Feed
