The Mystery of Deadman's Hole

The Mystery of Deadman's Hole | Bigfoot Story

11/8/2020

Vast and barren, deserts with their apparent lack of life are one of the spookiest places on the planet and the source of many supernatural tales. None are stranger than those told of the Borrego Sandman and the mystery of Deadman's Hole. | Host/Narrator – Marlene Pardo Pellicer

mystery_of_deadmans_hole_podcast.mp3
File Size:	38831 kb
File Type:	mp3

Download File

What is the creature that stalks the desert of the Borrego Badlands

Vast and barren, deserts with their apparent lack of life are one of the spookiest places on the planet and the source of many supernatural tales. The stark landscape lends itself to see the unimaginable, perhaps a mirage, or perhaps something more insidious.

In actuality deserts can be deadly for both humans and animals, and only the hardiest plants can survive there. Are the tales of strange beasts, mysterious sightings and ghostly visitors only the product of fevered, overheated brains? Perhaps what slithers, walks or glides along the unforgiving, hot sands appears only a moment in this dimension before they take what they want.

The desert keeps its secrets

The first strange stories tell of something that stalked the land of the Borrego Sink, 45 miles southeast of Borrego Springs, California. It’s described as an aggressive Bigfoot-type creature, named the Borrego Sasquatch. This dweller of the Borrego Badlands is seen in the arid spaces of the Anza-Borrego Desert State Park, and tales of this creature were first heard by Spanish missionaries arriving in San Diego in 1769. The natives called them "hairy devils". The Indians avoided the area of the Santa Ana River and called it towis puki, which translates to the "Camp of the Devil". They warned the missionaries to stay away, however as more settlers came to the area encounters were inevitable.

West of the Park is a 44,000 spread named Warner Ranch. There is a hollow known as Deadman’s Hole, which supposedly earned its name when a Butterfield stage driver found a dead man beside the spring. In another version five prospectors were drowned in a flash flood. Despite its ominous name, in the years to follow it became a stop off point for stagecoaches as they crisscrossed the desert.

Sightings of a strange creature were reported by passengers on the coaches, claiming that a hairy man would stare threateningly at them from behind brush. During these years, strange deaths occurred, and the victims appeared to have been savaged by an animal. The creature was believed to be the one who killed these people.

The place was described thus: "Between the years 1858 and 1890, the spot was truly haunted. Many prospectors in the vicinity disappeared into thin air, never to be seen again, until finally only the uninformed would venture near.”

In 1876 the Mendocino Democrat reported on an encounter by a prospector named Turner Helm:

The discovery of a wild man ten miles east of Warner's ranch, San Diego county. The writer says, 'Mr. Turner Helm and myself were in the mountains on a prospecting tour, looking for the extension of a quartz lead. The man was discovered by Mr. Helm, sitting on a boulder about 15 or 20 paces down from him. He appeared to be covered all over with coarse black hair, seemingly 2 or 3 inches long, like the hair of a bear, his beard and the hair of his head were long and thick.'

Anza Borrego State Park c.2017

The prospectors tried speaking to it in English, Spanish and the local Indian dialect, but it didn’t respond and just stared without uttering a sound. It walked towards them. They pulled out their firearms, and it only retreated when they aimed the rifles at it.

This land was a dangerous place; other murders could not be held against the strange creature. At Oak Grove, fifty miles in the interior of the county, a man named Robert Gunn, a resident of Warner's Ranch sent a letter to District Attorney Copeland advising of the murder of a woman who herded sheep.

This is the story reported by the San Francisco Examiner on January 8, 1888:

In a small adobe hut, lives a Mexican named Polito Escallier known by the settlers in the vicinity as 'Chihuahua.' He owned a small piece of land, on which the hut is situated, and quite a large flock of sheep and goats, and has for years passed his time in tending them.

A stepdaughter named Belita lived with Polito in the capacity of housekeeper, and at times cared for the goats and sheep. One evening Polito left for a ranch some distance away, informing Belita that he would return the following night. He never saw her alive again.

Early on the following evening Polito returned home. When he approached the hut he expected to see Belita but was disappointed. Thinking perhaps that she had allowed the goats to wander further away then usual, he entered and after partaking o f alight repast, rolled himself in his blanket, and being very tired was soon fast asleep.

The next morning when he awoke he was astonished to find himself alone in the hut. He arose quickly and at once started out to search for Belita.

He spent the whole day in looking for the girl but without success. The following morning he started for Oak Grove and there told of her disappearance. A party was immediately organized and a systematic search was instituted. In a clump of bushes about three miles away, they discovered the body of Belita.

She had been shot through the breast, the ball passing clear through the body. From an examination of the ground in the vicinity it was evident that she had been killed some little distance away, and the body had been dragged to the bush within which it was found for the purpose of concealment.

Nothing was found that would throw any light upon the murder.

Wildflowers at Anza Borrego

The summer before a man named William Blair was killed in the area, and the murder was never solved as well.

April 8, 1888 the San Diego Times described the encounter of what the men called a monster, half-human and half animal which had been killed at Deadman's Hole

Hunters seldom venture into Deadman's Hole partly because of the general awe and fear of the place, but more especially because it is well known that there is no game there.

Last Thursday, however two venturesome hunters named Edward Dean and Charles Cox, determined to explore the dark and mysterious cañon. Up to a certain point they had seen or heard nothing extraordinary, and the silence was quite oppressive when added to their natural fear of the mysterious place. The boulders and cuts in the cañon sides ahead of them were gradually becoming deeper and more impassable.

The explorers had almost made up their minds to turn back when suddenly they were startled by a slight rustle ahead of them, and almost immediately a crushing sound, as of some heavy object moving through the brush, was heard to proceed father up the cañon. The brush and rocks impeded the view, and the hunters scrambled up the cañon sides as quickly as they could to a commanding point.

The sight that met their gaze almost paralyzed them with fear. An immense, unwieldy animal, that from a rear view resembled a bear, was making rapid strides through the narrow defile. Its legs were long, and they were used with such ease and facility in climbing over the rocks and logs, that on second thought the animal appeared more like an immense gorilla. Its hair was dark brown, and it was at least 6 feet in height. The front legs, from their view, resembled arms, and the beast moved almost uprightly, like man or monkey. Its body was quite round and covered with extremely long hair, much unlike the hair of any animal. The hind legs, or feet from the knees down were the most peculiar features about the strange being. They were extremely broad and long, and the insides of them, upon which the animal walked were entirely bare of hair. Every time it made a move it exposed to view the bottoms of its immense paws. Except for the hair, the arms and hands of the beast greatly resembled those of a human being. The body was large and round, and entirely devoid of a tail.

As soon as the hunters recovered from their surprise they began to follow the beast. It had no difficulty in moving along, and was making rapid headway up the cañon. To call its attention and arrest its progress Cox suddenly fired a pistol shot in the air. At the report the beast stopped and turned its face toward its pursuers. It was now about 20 yards distant, in full view, and terror was added to the surprise of the adventurers. They saw before them a human countenance.

The animal turned almost instantly, and resumed its flight up the cañon. The hunters were now more eager than ever in their pursuit. At last, the beast suddenly disappeared in a narrow, obscure cut, full of brush and fallen trees and immense boulders. The next moment it was seen scrambling toward a small opening in the Rocky Mountain side. At that instant Cox, who is a wonderful shot with a rifle, brought his weapon to his shoulder and fired. With a cry like that of a human being, the beast instantly fell in a hideous heap across a boulder that it was in the act of scaling.

Slowly and with much trepidation the hunters made their way to the prostrate object. It proved to be dead, shot through the breast. The face was exposed to view as it lay on its side on the rock. The features were unmistakably human in character. The hairs on the face were few and black, and on the head it was long and jet black. The skin of the face was very dark and wrinkled. The teeth, which were partially exposed by the position of the mouth, were plainly those of a carnivorous animal. They were longer than those of a human being. This was the only feature about the face and head that did not exactly resemble the characteristics of a human.

Perhaps the most singular point about the strange creature was the disproportion between its head and body. The former was not larger than that of an ordinary man, and yet the body would weigh 400 pounds. The long, muscular arms were provided with a pair of hands almost exactly like those of a man. There were five fingers on each hand. The outside of the fingers were covered with hair, but on the inside was bare and white and thickly calloused in places. The feet, if such they could be called, were entirely unlike anything the hunters had ever seen. They were two feet long and eight inches broad and covered on the bottom with a hard substance, like that of a dog.

The being was of the male sex. It was evidently a cross between a human and some carnivorous animal. Such monstrosities, anthropologist say are often born in to the world, and many of them are mentioned in natural history.

After an examination of the body the hunters began an exploration of the opening toward which the animal was making its way. The entrance was under a large rock. The explorers advanced with caution, for fear of meeting a mate of the brute. A large apartment was found not more than 10 feet from the outside. It had evidently been dug out of the hard earth by hand. In the dim light it could be seen that the room was empty. Cox struck a match, and by its blaze all the mysteries surrounding the murders in Deadman's Hole were revealed. In one corner was pile of bones, among which were portions of human skeletons. Five human skulls were lying together. The half-man and half-beast was evidently also a semi-cannibal. On the floor, in the middle of the cave were the half-devoured remains of a goat. In another corner of the room was a pile of leaves and weeds which the animal used as a bed. These and the bones were the only objects in the cave.

The methods of the brute in its murderous work are evident. It sprang on its victims from behind and choked them to death. Then it would drag them to a place of concealment till nightfall. There is no doubt that if the bodies of Blair and Belita had not been found on the day they were murdered, they would never again have been heard of, as was the case with the many other mysterious disappearances in the Hole. The absence of human footprints or human motives, and all the other remarkable circumstance surrounding these murders, is now explained.

Sightings of the Borrego Sandman go back over a hundred years or more

In later years what has come to be known as the "Borrego Sandman" would continue to be occasionally sighted. In 1939, a man alone in the park set up his camp in a gulch. In the middle of the night he awoke to the sound of something moving around him. By the dying light of the campfire he saw several bipedal, silver-haired creatures with luminous red eyes that glowed in the darkness. They circled around him, but stayed away from the fire and eventually melted into the night.

In 1964, a father and son who were hiking through Escondido were pelted with rock from what they described as a shaggy beast.

West of Anza-Borrego near Jamul the MGM Ranch found three cows killed and mutilated. Strange tracks were around the carcasses.

Another person to have an encounter was US Marine, Victor Stonayow, who was exploring the area and came across three-toed tracks. They measured 14 inches long and 9 inches across. He claimed he took pictures and plaster casts but failed to produce them.

In 1968, Harold Lancaster who was camping in Borrego Sink encountered what he described thus:

I saw a man walking in the desert. The figure came closer. I thought it was another prospector. Then I picked up my binoculars and saw the strangest sight in my life: It was a real giant ape-man. I had heard about the screaming giant ape-man up in Tuolumne County that frightened people for a couple of years. Another person and I even went up there to look for the thing. I decided it was a hoax and never expected to actually see one. That thing was big. I was no match for it. I had a .22 pistol on my hip but it would have been like shooting at a gorilla with a pea shooter. I was afraid the beast might get too close. So, I fired a couple of rounds into the air. The sandman jumped a good three feet off the ground when the sounds of the shots reached him. He turned his head, looked toward me and then took off running in the other direction!

In 1985, a set of large, human-like tracks were found, and into the 1990s sporadic sightings were reported. Is it the same creature the Indians warned the missionaries about? And the question begs to be asked, is the Borrego Sandman still lurking in the sparse landscape of the Anza-Borrego Desert Park?