Worth More Dead than Alive; Trafficking in Human Remains

By M.P. Pellicer | Stranger Than Fiction Stories
Donating your body to science, doesn't guarantee that it will be used for this purpose. Instead it might become merchandise in a national network of human remains traffickers.

---

Cedric Lodge, who allegedly stole body parts donated to Harvard Medical School & sold them (Source - Twitter/KristinaRex)

Not even giving your body to a university can keep it safe. On Wednesday, June 14, 2023, Cedric Lodge the morgue manager who worked at Harvard Medical School since 1995, was indicted. He is facing federal changes of selling heads, brains, skin and other body parts. These were taken from cadavers donated to Harvard Medical School for research and education. Harvard fired him on May 6, 2023.

As the manager he removed human remains from his job site in Boston to his home in Goffstown, New Hampshire, along with different organs and body parts from donated cadavers after they had been used for teaching purposes, and took them to his homes where they were sold and shipped out. In some cases customers would pick up their purchases themselves and transport them home.

Lodge allowed buyers access to the morgue to make their purchase, or shipped them out, in some cases through the United States Postal Service.

---

A woman is pictured with what appears to be a Satanic-themed tattoo on Denise Lodge's Facebook page (Source - Facebook)

His wife, Denise worked at the New Hampshire Department of Health and Human Services as a data analyst until 2014.

Pictures on Denise’s Facebook profile show a woman with a shaven head with what appears to be a satanic motif tattooed on it.  It is not clear if the woman with the tattoo is Denise or someone else.

Buyers have also been named in the indictment. They are: Joshua Taylor, of West Lawn, Pennsylvania and Katrina MacLean, of Salem, Massachusetts, who owned and operated a business called Kat's Creepy Creations in Peabody, Massachusetts. 

---

Jeremy Lee Pauley buys and sells body parts (Source Jeremy Pauley/Facebook)

MacLean resold some of the specimens to buyers in other states. One of them is Jeremy Pauley, who is executive director and curator at The Memento Mori Museum, according to his Facebook. He owns The Grand Wunderkammer - which sells "odd and unusual" items to the public and to museum exhibits. 

Pauley was the one who provided the name of Cedric Lodge as one of his suppliers.

Pauley, 41, has previous arrests. In August, 2022 he was charged with "abuse of a corpse, receiving stolen property and dealing in the proceeds of unlawful activities." This involved Candace Chapman Scott who worked at a crematorium who was partnered with the University of Arkansas. She is accused of selling the corpses of two stillborn babies meant to be cremated, and selling them instead to Pauley. He is known to purchase pelvis "antiques" and "very old skulls" belonging to children.

---

Pauley selling bones on Facebook (Source - Jeremy Pauley/Facebook)

Prior to this in October 2020, MacLean sold skin and two dissected faces for $600. Pauley tanned the skin making it into leather and sold it back to MacLean. 

In the indictment, Pauley paid $8,800 to MacLean, and a total of $40,049 to Taylor, all through PayPal.

Pauley has over 5,000 followers on Facebook.

Harvard is now left trying to explain to the families of the deceased, who in many cases donated the body of their loved ones, that the corpses were desecrated and not studied.

Since then family members have sued HMS Morgue, along with Cedric Lodge and his supervisors.

In August 2023, Jeremy Pauley who was accused of illegally buying and selling human remains went to court on four charges levied against him. He initially told police he legally bought 3 skeletons and other body parts, but this was before police found multiple buckets in his basement full of human remains. He was charged for buying: "Half of a head, a whole head missing a skull cap, three brains with a skull cap, a heart, aliver, a lung, two kidneys, a female pelvis, a piece of skin with a nipple and four hands for $4,000."

---

Jeremy Lee Pauley advertised “one last small run of bone dice” on his Facebook page in June. (Source - Facebook)

The transaction took place over Facebook Marketplace, and sent through USPS.

The illegal sales took place after Pauley's ex-wife, Sarah Pauley went into the basement after he moved out, and found the gallon buckets with the horrible remains.

A few weeks earlier, police had visited the house after an anonymous tip of “possible human body parts being sold on Facebook,” but they did not have a search warrant and did not visit the basement. She feared Pauley would now try to frame her for what she had discovered.

This investigation led to Cedric Lodge at Harvard Medical School's morgue, Candace Chapman Scott the mortuary worker in Arkansas, Katrina Maclean and Joshua Taylor.

By the summer of 2022, Pauley had become violent with his wife who once posed with specimens he was trying to sell. She told police he threatened to kill her, and cut her into pieces if she ever left him. This information was part of the of temporary restraining order she sought for her protection. He said he wasn't afraid of doing prison time, since he did a stretch in 2003 for stabbing his girlfriend.

Oddity collectors buy and sell objects of interest having to do with natural history, taxidermy, antiquities, quack medicine and the paranormal.

Pauley agreed to a plea deal and became a cooperating witness.

---

In 2023 after he was under investigation Jeremy Pauley posted on Facebook, saying he made candles from human tallow. (Source J. Pauley/Facebook)

In 2024, Denise Lodge pled guilty to transporting stolen human remains taken from donor bodies, something she and her husband Cedric had done since 2018. He had been working there for almost 30 years. The charge she pleaded guilty to carries a sentence of up to 10 years in prison and a fine of $250,000, but the  charge could have been harsher if she went to trial with the case. It's not certain if she will testify against the other that have been charged.

In May, 2025 Cedric Lodge, 57, pled guilty to interstate transport of stolen human remains. The maximum penalty under federal law is 10 years, plus probation and a fine. He admitted that between 2018 to 2020 he sold transported human remains stolen from the Harvard Medical School morgue.

The investigation into Jeremy Pauley led authorities to the Lodges and their sale of human body parts.

Pauley pled guilty in Pennsylvania state court to federal charges of conspiracy to commit interstate transportation of stolen property and interstate transportation of stolen property. It's estimated Pauley paid between $45,000 and $95,000 for the body parts.

---

Screenshot of an online listing for human remains, posted more than two years after Jeremy Pauley was first arrested for his involvement in the human remains trade. (Source Middle District of Pennsylvania U.S. Attorney's Office)

UPDATE DECEMBER, 2025
In December, 2025, Pauley, 43 was sentenced to 72 months for conspiracy and interstate transportation of stolen property. In addition he was ordered to pay $2000 fine and serve 3 years on supervised released following his sentence. He started serving his sentence on January 16, 2026.

Despite his guilty plea in 2023, prosecutors stated Pauley continued to engage in the trade after his arrest, even opening a new shop. Federal prosecutors had sought a 15-year sentence, arguing he relished his notoriety and showed no remorse.  

By the time of Pauley's conviction in December, 2025 other defendants had entered guilty pleas in related cases, including Joshua Taylor, Andrew Ensanian, Matthew Lampi, Katrina Maclean, Cedric and Denise Lodge, and Angelo Pereyra. 

Lampi was sentenced to 15 months in prison; Pereyra was sentenced to 18 months in prison; Ensanian was sentenced to six months in prison; Denise and Cedric Lodge were sentenced to 12 months and a day and 96 months in prison.

Candace Chapman-Scott, who stole remains from an Arkansas crematorium where she was employed and sold them to Pauley in Pennsylvania, entered a plea of guilty in Arkansas federal court and was sentenced to 15 years in prison. 

​"The mother of one of the stillborn babies told the court at Chapman Scott's sentencing that she will be tortured by what happened to her son for the rest of her life. 'I have to think about not only my child being sent through the mail like an Amazon package, but who all touched him? Who all came in contact with him,' she said, according to court filings. 'We had a beautiful memorial for him, and he wasn't even there.'"

Joshua Taylor and Katrina Maclean are awaiting sentencing. Both pled guilty to interstate transport of stolen goods.

---